Stats
- Episodes featuring their films
- 4
- Movies in this archive
- 4
Rewatchables episodes featuring Laurie Metcalf’s films
Mentioned in discussions
The Butch’s Girlfriend Award for the Weakest Link in the Film
Carter’s final death scene
In the discussion (2)
- Carter’s final death scene is selected as the weakest element. — Bill Simmons
- A more forceful lawyer is suggested as an improvement. — Chris Ryan
Probably Unanswerable Questions
Questions concern a possible Stallone jab, interchangeable supporting actresses and the original teacher’s fate.
In the discussion (3)
- Naming the doll-playing child Sylvester is speculated to be a Schwarzenegger/Stallone rivalry jab; Dominic’s name is also queried without an answer. — Bill Simmons
- Pamela Reed and Laurie Metcalf are compared as excellent, potentially interchangeable actors, with Internal Affairs cited. — Bill Simmons
- The displaced teacher’s job and tenure are questioned; an invented return followed by Kimball replacing her again imagines her leaving teaching. — Kyle Brandt
What’s Aged the Best?
Evidence planting; menswear and haircuts; Los Angeles; Figgis; Metcalf; marriage tension; co-parenting; revised ending; mall security; cuckolding.
In the discussion (13)
- Evidence planting remains an effective fictional device, especially before ubiquitous cameras and phones.
- The good investigator beginning to resemble the corrupt man he pursues. — Bill Simmons
- Off-duty menswear, including Gere's polo and sunglasses, remains contemporary. — Chris Ryan
- Figgis contributing music and appearing as Nancy Travis's dinner companion. — Chris Ryan
- Los Angeles as a vibrant crime-film setting, and Gere and Garcia's early-1990s haircuts. — Bill Simmons
- Laurie Metcalf excels despite a limited role and has strong chemistry with Garcia. — Bill Simmons
- The unusual sexual slang root, made ironic by Peck's affair with Van's wife.
- Unfinished suburban developments as crime-film locations and suspiciously expensive houses revealing corruption.
- Faye Grant's performance and the tense Garcia–Travis marriage, with her sexual frustration and his fixation on work. — Bill Simmons
- Peck's unconventional co-parenting and the dirty-cop excuse that a woman is his informant.
- Replacing the convoluted original ending, with a threatened assault, shooting, window fall and apparent drowning, after hostile test reactions. — Bill Simmons
- Xander Berkeley as Rudy and cops forced to work second jobs as mall security.
- The cuckolding theme is much more widely recognized in contemporary culture.
Half-Assed Internet Research
Production anecdotes cover Caan, the actors’ rehearsal conflict, adaptations, effects, and King’s addiction metaphor
In the discussion (9)
- James Caan reportedly had unusable footage after arriving hungover and reimbursed the studio — Bill Simmons
- Some dialogue is suspected of having been looped, though the reason is uncertain — Bill Simmons
- Stephen King is reported to have called Annie Wilkes his favorite character — Bill Simmons
- Caan preferred discovery during filming while Bates preferred rehearsal; Reiner found a middle ground — Bill Simmons
- A 2015 Broadway adaptation starred Bruce Willis and Laurie Metcalf and used a Goldman script — Bill Simmons
- Castle Rock season two also adapted Annie Wilkes material — Bill Simmons
- A DVD feature described Annie as a broad catalog of mental illness — Bill Simmons
- The hobbling prosthetics used gelatin legs, wires, and openings in the bed for Caan’s real legs — Bill Simmons
- King later explained Annie and the hobbling as metaphors for his drug dependence and inability to escape it — Bill Simmons
Half-Assed Internet Research
George Clooney and Michael O'Keefe both played boyfriends of Laurie Metcalf on Roseanne; Michael Clayton was Catherine Waterston's first feature; Brian Koppelman is the poker player who roasts Michael about hair plugs; the horses appear in Realm and Conquer; Tony Gilroy spent a couple of years getting it made and Clooney passed once or twice
In the discussion (5)
- Both George Clooney and Michael O'Keefe, who plays Barry, played boyfriends of Laurie Metcalf on Roseanne.
- Catherine Waterston (as transcribed) makes her first feature appearance as the lawyer in the Milwaukee hotel room who answers Michael's questions about who is taking the deposition and where his briefcase is.
- The player roasting Michael at the Chinatown poker table is Rounders and Billions writer and friend of the Ringer Brian Koppelman, who subjects himself to a hair-plugs joke ('you bought yourself some new hair' / 'yeah, with your money'); the film has spawned little controversy or behind-the-scenes drama.
- Tony Gilroy tried to make the film for a couple of years and George Clooney passed on it once or twice, but it was ultimately a smooth ship; it did not do well at the box office yet became a touchstone people wish Hollywood still made.
- Teased earlier as half-assed internet research: the horses appear in Realm and Conquer.
Probably Unanswerable Questions
What is the next day of school like for Sidney? What does the house's owner fix first? How much does Sidney regret losing her virginity to the killer? What would you do when the murders start? Why did the killers not finish her? Was there a Scream 20th anniversary? Is the lack of diversity intentional? What expo was Sidney's father headed to?
In the discussion (10)
- What is the next day of school like for Neve Campbell's character? She is done for the rest of the year, though strong-willed enough to try to come back early, and the principal is dead too.
- What does the house's owner fix first? The garage door before the blood, or simply bulldoze the house and sell the land after fifteen murders and fifty gallons of corn syrup, since it becomes a Halloween tourist attraction.
- The virginity subplot winks at the earlier movies where the girl who did not have sex survived; how much does Sidney regret that her first time was with the killer ten minutes before his spree, and how does she tell later partners?
- Scream 2 arrives two years later with Sidney, after more trauma than any human, simply going to college and a sorority; one host does not acknowledge Scream 2 and 3, though the Jerry O'Connell cafeteria song and Laurie Metcalf are liked while the long ending with the mother drags.
- Asked what to do when the murders start at the party: just run away, out to the middle of the street where nobody can sneak up, for two miles if needed, saving nobody.
- Flipped around: with Neve Campbell hard to kill, the killers were toying with her and should have finished it when he had her in the Jeep, like the Wolf Creek killer stabbing straight through the car seat, or Oberyn Martell failing to finish the Mountain in Game of Thrones.
- The killer toying with the last girl was a horror staple of the era, as when Jamie Lee Curtis drops the knife beside Michael Myers; the final-girl flirtation is a trope shared with James Bond and Six Million Dollar Man.
- Was there a Scream 20th anniversary? Scream 4 in 2011 updated it with Emma Roberts and was not great, and MTV made a Scream TV show nobody here watched; self-reference can only go so far before it becomes Airplane, and Scream 4 lays it on thick.
- Last question: is the astonishing lack of diversity intentional? Probably unintentional and corrected in Scream 2 with Jada Pinkett Smith and a Black best friend; no minority with a speaking line is recalled, a cast that would never happen today, and the filmmakers would likely claim it was a statement about how white earlier movies were.
- Earlier, what expo Sidney's father is heading to after the attack is asked.

