Picking Nits
Geography; riddles; surviving injuries; gold logistics; Simon’s monitoring and aspirin clue
In the discussion (17)
- Holly’s refusal to move back from Los Angeles is questioned after McClane’s ordeals.
- Getting to Yankee Stadium so quickly strains New York geography.
- From the Yankee Stadium diversion onward, the ending feels improvised even though it remains enjoyable.
- The crowded stoop and open repair shop seem implausibly active before school starts; the store is corrected from a pawnshop to an electronics repair business.
- Escaping ten attackers after being struck with a bottle seems unlikely.
- The subway bomb should cause greater damage and deaths.
- McClane might have recognized the German connection sooner after being told about Simon’s accent.
- The riddles seem too difficult to solve so quickly; whether Simon expects success is raised as a counterpoint.
- Zeus abandoning an unlocked shop and rarely worrying about it is questioned; the objection is corrected because he does mention its likely destruction.
- Simon’s apparent ability to observe each task and the logistics of his large mercenary crew are questioned.
- Simon’s claim to be a soldier rather than a monster conflicts with bombing an occupied subway, even if the blast serves the heist.
- The heroes accumulate blood, gunshot injuries, crashes, falls, flooding and cable fragments yet remain mobile; McClane is jokingly likened to Unbreakable’s protagonist.
- McClane’s lack of temptation by the enormous stolen fortune, or even a single gold bar, is questioned and compared with Marathon Man’s rejected diamonds.
- The uniformly tall German henchmen and Simon’s false American persona should be obvious impostors rather than credible police or city workers.
- Surviving the flooded tunnel and being shot into the air exactly as Zeus drives past is the decisive implausibility.
- The anti-lock-brake maneuver is nevertheless admired as a striking stunt.
- Simon’s meticulous plan is undermined by handing over the identifying aspirin bottle; replacing the gang’s gold with scrap should also be discovered.