Categories & segments

Burke’s scheme; Newt’s parents; Newt / missing motivation

The older children, with disagreement about the ending

The jump’s physics, the extra subway act and Jack’s punch lines

Avery’s Riverside detour, the missing first murder, and reliance on Donald Cheney’s claims are the main weak-link concerns.

Laurie’s drugged incapacitation is the majority weak link; Dick Warlock’s shorter, stiffer, ill-fitting-mask Michael is the dissent.

Herb Stempel was named as the rewatchability weak link because he is a difficult hang, while his importance and Turturro’s work were defended.

Jack Crawford wins unanimously; one participant also criticizes the anagram-and-puzzle structure as comparatively clunky.

The three-year, two-month, fourteen-day running sequence is the weak link.

The conspiracy’s murder plan

The panel split between Jordan’s implausible rapid competence and Seagal disappearing into the refrigerator for too much of the movie.

Angie’s thin, reworked girlfriend plot wins, despite a defense of Heard’s phone performances.

The category is deliberately left blank because the panel supports the film’s decisions.