Demi Moore, plus many alternate Tess candidates.
Michelle Pfeiffer, Madonna, Shelley Long, Lorraine Bracco, Whoopi Goldberg, Goldie Hawn, Meg Ryan, and Cher are discussed; Mike Nichols insisted on Melanie Griffith.
In the discussion (5)
Young Marisa Tomei or Mira Sorvino as Doreen.
The director and city are otherwise retained.
In the discussion (2)
- A young Marisa Tomei is proposed for Doreen.
- “Miroservino” is proposed for Doreen.
Griffith–Baldwin history; Mike Nichols; World Trade Center lobby; White House screening.
The George H. W. Bush screening and “dirty parts” warning are retained as reported context.
In the discussion (3)
- A reported interview says Melanie Griffith made passes at Alec Baldwin and was rejected.
- Mike Nichols and the Seven World Trade Center lobby are research topics.
- A New York Times account reports a first-week White House screening hosted by George H. W. Bush.
White wedding clothes; office secrecy; broken-leg recovery; Katharine’s vacation; Mick’s affair and proposal.
Multiple timeline, workplace, and character-logic objections are retained.
In the discussion (17)
- Tess wearing white to the wedding is criticized.
- Nobody questioning Tess’s repeated use of Katharine’s office is criticized.
- Katharine’s rapid recovery from a severe broken leg is challenged.
- Whether Katharine would be fired for stealing the idea is debated.
- Katharine vacationing soon after transfer is challenged.
- A previously planned vacation and perhaps ten days or a couple of weeks on the job are offered as explanations.
- Katharine expecting a proposal but traveling without Jack is challenged.
- She knew many people at the resort, knew the hotel operator, and had enough money to take the trip anyway.
- Alec Baldwin having sex with Doreen in Tess’s bed is challenged as implausibly brazen.
- His Motor Trend reading and birthday lingerie gift are cited as signs he might cheat; adultery is also framed as more culturally tolerated in the period.
- Mick proposing publicly only days later is challenged.
- Tess answering “maybe” is defended as fair and as a good movie scene.
- The friends encouraging Tess to accept despite knowing about the affair is challenged.
- Period gender norms and a boys-will-be-boys attitude are offered as explanations for the friends’ response.
- Mick’s boat-loan business is questioned.
- High-school coach is proposed as an alternate job, then rejected because he should not be near students.
- Used-car salesman is proposed as a better-fitting job.
Meaning of Let the River Run; Jack and Katharine’s relationship; office-party dumplings; Ford sex scenes; whether Tess is the villain.
Each question receives debate rather than a manufactured resolution.
In the discussion (5)
- The lyrics and river in Let the River Run are questioned.
- The panel asks how Jack and Katharine progressed beyond a casual or strategic relationship. — Joanna Robinson
- Dim sum dumplings as passed office-party food are questioned and mostly rejected.
- The panel asks whether Harrison Ford has explicit sex scenes beyond Presumed Innocent.
- The panel asks whether Tess can be viewed as the villain for taking her boss’s boyfriend and opportunity.
Baby Boom is the final preference; many alternatives.
Broadcast News, Morning Glory, Pretty Woman, Witness, and The Devil Wears Prada are also proposed.
In the discussion (6)
- Baby Boom and Broadcast News are proposed as a triple-feature extension.
- Morning Glory is proposed.
- Pretty Woman is proposed for its Cinderella parallels.
- Witness is proposed for another Harrison Ford performance.
- The Devil Wears Prada is proposed for workplace-story parallels.
- Baby Boom becomes the final preference.