Dr. Patel is the main job-competence candidate: vague advice, blurred boundaries and deliberately playing Pat’s triggering song in the waiting room are criticized as unprofessional.
The police officer is a runner-up for inconsistent enforcement and constant availability, though his appearances and flirting work as a comic device.
Pat Senior’s bookmaking is questioned because his business seems to consist of risky Eagles bets with Randy; Randy’s precise role remains uncertain.
The judge awarding a 5.3 is another job-competence nominee, with disagreement over whether the dance deserves that score; Dr. Patel is the final choice.
Chris Tucker’s Danny is proposed as weak link because his friend role overlaps Ronnie’s and his trips from Baltimore strain plausibility, not because of the performance.
Others defend Tucker’s wounded, off-kilter performance, the destabilizing humor of his visits and his jailhouse-lawyer exchange with De Niro; a hoped-for dramatic lead career did not follow.
The depiction of mental health and the leads’ age gap are aged-worst candidates; the film leaves Pat’s medication adherence less explicit than it could, although a later line indicates he is taking it.
The suggestion of special perception through mental illness raises concerns, while the parents’ fear and desire to help feel truthful; the romantic fantasy and reported personal investment of the filmmakers complicate the criticism.
Russell’s reputation and reported treatment of actors are aged-worst concerns; Zach recalls Bale confirming intervention during American Hustle and mentions other publicly reported confrontations. — Zach Baron
The panel argues for interpreting the film as a personally meaningful romantic fantasy rather than requiring it to represent every experience of mental illness.
Memories of Andy Reid’s late Eagles years and the contrast with his later Chiefs offense are another aged-worst choice.
Explaining a parlay seems dated given gambling’s increased familiarity, though another participant appreciates the explanation.
The near-erasure of the Phillies championship is recalled as an aged-worst issue and deferred to nitpicks.
The existing title is praised; Fly Eagles Fly, Dallas Sucks, DeSean Jackson Jersey and Excelsior are joking alternatives, with Excelsior’s New York association noted.
The garbage bag is disliked as another embarrassing Philadelphia image and its usefulness is questioned; a pickle-juice alternative is joked about.
Jacki Weaver is called good in the role but questionable casting because the mother could have supplied a convincing Philadelphia accent; Melissa Leo is proposed instead.
De Niro’s Oscar nomination and comeback narrative are questioned even while his performance and renewed engagement are appreciated.
Randy’s behavior is considered implausibly tolerated: a Cowboys fan flirting with Pat Senior’s wife and threatening the family’s livelihood would face confrontation.
Tiffany is provocatively compared to the Joker for manipulating Pat through the forged letter and promise of his estranged wife’s presence.
The characters feel psychologically Philadelphian without sounding local; avoiding accents has defenders, while a genuinely local actress is imagined and Nikki’s actor is identified as being from Philadelphia.
Reported earlier casting included Vince Vaughn with Zooey Deschanel, Mark Wahlberg as Pat and Anne Hathaway as Tiffany; the panel doubts these alternatives could match the final pairing.
Lawrence’s toughness and partly goth styling are essential to avoiding cuteness; Vaughn might make a functional but lesser film, while Rob McElhenney and Kat Dennings are joking alternatives.
De Niro wins overacting for his explosive reactions; the film’s heightened style and unsubtle parallels between father and son complicate the choice, while his stadium exclusion is praised as a detail.
Amy Adams is the recasting-couch suggestion for Nikki to make the final romantic choice less obvious, though the small, unappealing assignment is joked about.
Displaying discussions 4789 - 4800 of 8676 in total
