The opening monologue, Annie's marriage announcement, Brian's introduction, the guest-list cut, blender fight, and basketball montage are praised; the final choice is the family dinner where Annie announces her engagement.

In the discussion (13)

Approx. transcript time · 00:27:15Read transcript

The opening direct-to-camera monologue works despite the panel's usual skepticism about narration because Steve Martin sells the writing.
The narration lets George express fears he cannot tell his family until the end.
Annie's marriage announcement is rewatchable for Steve Martin's horrified reaction to his twenty-two-year-old daughter getting engaged.
The flashback that replaces Annie with her seven-year-old self captures a parent's inability to see a child as an adult.
Diane Keaton's growing happiness during the announcement contrasts with Martin's panic and makes the family dynamic visible.
The dialogue about Paul Simon tickets and an independent communications consultant supplies specific comic detail.
Brian's first meeting with George works because the son-in-law is pleasant and unthreatening enough to leave the story centered on the family.
Cutting the wedding list is funny because its ruthless logic includes crossing off a guest who died.
Kimberly Williams sells Annie's disproportionate anger during the blender fight.
George helping resolve the blender fight shows that love for his daughter overrides his resistance to the marriage.
Steve Martin opening the feared gift box only to find a blender gives the scene a physical-comedy payoff.
The childhood montage into the basketball scene combines Darling with a sentimental father-daughter memory.
The final family-dinner choice establishes every central relationship and lets each actor react differently to the engagement.

What’s Aged the Best?

Kieran Culkin, Kimberly Williams, San Marino, the basketball scene, the overwhelmed father, changing marriage norms, and the hot-dog arithmetic all receive praise.

In the discussion (12)

Approx. transcript time · 00:38:54Read transcript

Kieran Culkin's small reactions are newly funny because the child performance anticipates his later Roman Roy mannerisms.
The child performance plays the role simply and still nails the few kid-scene-stealing moments.
Kimberly Williams is delightful and immediately believable as Steve Martin's daughter.
Williams and Martin create father-daughter chemistry even in quiet basketball movement.
The movie defined Williams so strongly as Annie that the panel had difficulty imagining an obvious next role for her.
San Marino is praised as an unusually pleasant, beautiful Southern California setting.
The basketball scene is unusually convincing for a movie father-daughter game.
The montage shows enough continuous movement to suggest that Steve Martin made at least one trick shot himself.
An overwhelmed father struggling to afford a wedding remains a durable comic plot.
The wedding-planning escalation still feels accurate because small decisions rapidly add expense and complexity.
The film is presented as marking the baby-boomer generation's move away from countercultural ideas of marriage.
The hot-dog and bun mismatch remains relatable because mismatched package quantities still create needless arithmetic.

What’s Aged the Worst?

Marriage at twenty-two, the sequel and pandemic Zoom special, wedding parking, some wardrobe choices, the pool gag, and especially Martin Short's accent routine are criticized.

In the discussion (11)

Approx. transcript time · 00:48:41Read transcript

Annie getting married at twenty-two felt abrupt even in 1991 and seems more unusual now.
Father of the Bride Part II is treated as a mild money grab, although affection for the family keeps it watchable.
The virtual pandemic sequel recalls a period of low entertainment standards that the panel does not want to revisit.
A hundred wedding cars and casual drunk-driving assumptions make the parking setup feel dated.
Some of Diane Keaton's high-waisted khaki and denim wardrobe reads as dated but is also returning to fashion.
Casting Diane Keaton as a bride's mother felt like a hook in 1991, even though the role now seems natural.
The fall into the pool pushes the movie beyond its otherwise grounded physical comedy.
The earlier medicine-cabinet and window gags are defended as physical comedy grounded in George's panic.
The dogs remain funny and useful even though the pool fall is rejected as too silly.
Martin Short's hard-to-understand accent is criticized as a one-note routine that repeats too long.
The accent gag is the final and least-favorite answer.

The Joey Pants “That Guy” Award

George Newbern as Brian wins over B.D. Wong because his long television career and more than 350 audiobook credits surprised the panel.

In the discussion (5)

Approx. transcript time · 00:58:42Read transcript

B.D. Wong is the first That Guy candidate but is judged to have graduated from the category.
George Newbern is proposed because the panel knew him as Brian without knowing his name.
Newbern is reported to have more than 350 Audible narration credits as of September 2020.
His television work on Scandal and Providence reinforces the selection.
George Newbern receives the final award.

The Ruffalo / Hanna / Rubinek / Partridge Overacting Award

Martin Short wins for the largest and most sustained performance in the movie.

In the discussion (2)

Approx. transcript time · 01:00:36Read transcript

Martin Short is the immediate overacting choice.
The participants call it most overacting rather than best overacting.

The Dion Waiters Award for Best Heat Check Performance

Kieran Culkin wins over Eugene Levy and B.D. Wong; Diane Keaton is ruled too substantial for the category.

In the discussion (5)

Approx. transcript time · 01:00:59Read transcript

The one-scene Eugene candidate is considered for the award.
B.D. Wong is praised for expressive reactions and for adding energy to his supporting role.
Diane Keaton is ruled ineligible because she has too much screen time and is the second-biggest star.
Kieran Culkin is admitted based on his few memorable moments and tender pre-wedding exchange with George.
The final exchange gives the award to the child performer.

Apex Mountain

Mainstream Steve Martin, Kimberly Williams, San Marino, father-daughter movies, and wedding movies receive apex cases; Diane Keaton, Nancy Meyers, and dads do not.

In the discussion (9)

Approx. transcript time · 01:04:35Read transcript

Steve Martin's late-1970s comedy peak is distinguished from a possible mainstream-dad peak beginning with this film.
The movie is argued to enable Martin's later Oscars-host and America's-dad roles.
Diane Keaton is rejected because Annie Hall and Something's Gotta Give offer stronger career peaks.
Kimberly Williams receives a yes based on her defining role.
Father-daughter movies receive an unqualified apex verdict.
San Marino receives an emphatic yes.
Dads receive a tentative but explicit probably-not verdict.
Wedding movies receive an apex case because this film builds an entire happy story around the wedding.
The film is credited with helping start a 1990s wave including Four Weddings and a Funeral, The Wedding Planner, and The Wedding Singer.

Sequel, Prequel, Limited Series, or All-Black Remake

The panel first rejects a ten-episode remake, then accepts a well-funded continuation with the original couple as grandparents and Annie's family at the center.

In the discussion (5)

Approx. transcript time · 01:18:26Read transcript

The first answer to a ten-episode Netflix version is please no.
Affection for the family means even a flawed remake would still be watched.
The acceptable version would keep Steve Martin and Diane Keaton as grandparents while Kimberly Williams and George Newbern become the parents.
The panel insists on a real budget and full cast rather than another Zoom production.
The skeptical participant is fully persuaded in under ninety seconds.

What Piece of Memorabilia Would You Want From This Movie?

After ruling out the house, the choices are the cappuccino maker and Annie's wedding sneakers.

In the discussion (5)

Approx. transcript time · 01:27:43Read transcript

The house, its front, and the kitchen are requested before the house is ruled off the table.
The bedazzled wedding sneakers are proposed as a practical and emotionally resonant item.
The panel wonders whether George's Sidekick shoe company was acquired or merged with Foot Locker and doubts that it thrived against Nike.
The cappuccino maker is chosen because its scene is sweet.
The final choices are the cappuccino maker and the sneakers.

Who Won the Movie?

Both participants choose Steve Martin, while Nancy Meyers receives an alternate case.

In the discussion (3)

Approx. transcript time · 01:29:09Read transcript

The first winner response is Steve Martin.
The second participant agrees that it has to be Steve Martin.
Nancy Meyers receives an alternate case because this film helped her later career cohere, but the panel says her apex came later.

Podcast choices

Speaker not identified: Steve Martin
Speaker not identified: Steve Martin