St. Elmo's Fire poster
St. Elmo's Fire

What’s Aged the Worst?

Wendy's wardrobe and weight plot; Kirby's stalking of Dale; Dale's understanding boyfriend; the glamorous apartments; time spent on Wendy's family

In the discussion (11)
Approx. transcript time · 00:49:33Read transcript
  • Wendy is dressed like a 1950s librarian, and making her weight a plot point is odd.
  • Billy's attraction to Wendy is inexplicable given his wife and bar habits; she is called miscast.
  • Andrew McCarthy is called miscast, with unintentional comedy through the roof; the other host likes him in the film.
  • The actor's smoking as Kevin looks learned the day before filming, and Kevin is compared to Troy in Reality Bites, though Troy's friendships make more sense.
  • Nobody notices Kevin is in love with Leslie, and Alec's cheating seems constant.
  • The Dale and Kirby plot has aged far worse than anything involving Kevin.
  • Kirby is a stalker: the rain-soaked black-tie arrival likened to Buffalo Bill, sniffing the pillow, and leaving his own party to drive three hours to the ski house.
  • Kirby has no other plot beyond law school, the DUI help, switching jobs and returning to law school; he takes bar orders as if nothing happened.
  • Dale's understanding boyfriend at the ski house, who even starts Kirby's car, is ridiculous.
  • The apartments are too glamorous for 22-year-olds; Schumacher is quoted saying youth movies deserved stars, clothes, sets and cars, and that glamour was very much his concept.
  • Too much time goes to Wendy's family with Martin Balsam instead of Jules; in a 10-episode version viewers would skip the Wendy episode.