Most Rewatchable Scene
Best Day, Worst Day scene; plane ride home from running with the bulls; Nancy confronting Phil at the party
In the discussion (11)
Approx. transcript time · 00:27:04Read transcript
- The plane ride back from running with the bulls is a favorite: Mitch's sore-rear dad jokes, Ed being told he'll soon be dating sperm, Phil pretending to sleep, and the question of when it will ever be enough.
- The Crystal-Tambor office scene is called weird, but the pizza ad is perfect, and the 'as good as you're ever going to look' line sets up the movie.
- The school scene with the guy from Total Recall is called crushing it, and it marks Jake Gyllenhaal's debut with a spiked haircut.
- The fireplace scene where Kirby and Stern fight is nominated.
- The harmonica scene between Jack and Billy is quoted and all their scenes together are praised.
- Curly's 'one thing' secret-of-life scene is quoted.
- Best Day, Worst Day is called 'my favorite, most rewatchable... the best scene,' with the story of standing up to his father quoted.
- Mitch's description of first walking into Yankee Stadium after seeing it on black-and-white TV is called pretty awesome, but his being a Mets fan is flagged as the number one nit.
- One answer says the movie falls apart in the last 40 minutes with no rewatchable scenes there, and picks Nancy the cashier confronting Phil about her pregnancy at the party.
- Best Day, Worst Day is the pick, and Kirby is phenomenal in that scene. — Sean Fennessey
- Underwood's staging of the stampede is floated as most rewatchable; the reply grants parts are beautiful but calls it a flat-looking Western with a good script and great bones, likened to Raiders.