Categories & segments

In the discussion (3)
Approx. transcript time · 01:11:17Read transcript
  • Vince Vaughn is the selection, with his shouting at his mother compared to Will Ferrell’s work during the same period, explicitly stopping short of an accusation of stealing.
  • Vaughn’s performance feels improvised without enough purpose or memorable material, although his presence is still welcome.
  • A shorter office cameo might have worked better than giving Vaughn the third-largest amount of screen time.
In the discussion (3)
Approx. transcript time · 01:15:09Read transcript
  • Michelle Monaghan is nominated for one brief, eccentric scene.
  • The I-Team member administering stitches receives a nomination for precise work in a very short appearance.
  • Adam Brody is nominated but also rated only C-plus because the part wants his essence without giving him enough lines.
In the discussion (3)
Approx. transcript time · 01:15:41Read transcript
  • For Vaughn’s role at the time, Owen Wilson and 2005 Bradley Cooper are considered, with Cooper bringing an angrier edge; Byron Mayo is jokingly floated.
  • Dave Chappelle becomes the preferred replacement for Vaughn.
  • Ghosted’s Chris Evans and Ana de Armas are offered as a modern comparison but dismissed as lacking chemistry; Anyone but You inspires more anticipation. Tom Holland and Zendaya are floated as the biggest current couple, followed by a joking on-set breakup scenario.
Mr. and Mrs. Smith poster
Mr. and Mrs. Smith

Apex Mountain

Jolie; Pitt, qualified; 21st-century celebrity culture; fighting spy couples, tentative; Brody; on-set romances for this century, disputed

In the discussion (8)
Approx. transcript time · 01:22:28Read transcript
  • Jolie is an affirmative choice.
  • Pitt is an affirmative choice based on becoming perhaps the world’s most famous actor, while Moneyball and the intervening run remain alternatives.
  • Twenty-first-century celebrity culture receives agreement.
  • Fighting spy couples receives a tentative yes, but assassins or hit men more broadly do not.
  • Vaughn is rejected and The Bourne Identity is preferred for Liman.
  • Brody receives an emphatic yes because this film coincided with his O.C. fame, recalling hopes he could become the next Tom Hanks.
  • Marriage-counseling movies receives a no without a clear alternative.
  • On-set romances is disputed: Taylor and Burton are preferred overall, while Pitt and Jolie are defended at least for the twenty-first century.
Mr. and Mrs. Smith poster
Mr. and Mrs. Smith

Picking Nits

Missed bullets; Bogotá climate; unclear agencies; urinating stance; undiscovered marriage; meal deliveries; low bounties; secret weapons installations

In the discussion (8)
Approx. transcript time · 01:24:28Read transcript
  • The couple avoids every bullet despite scores of attackers in the final store battle.
  • The hot, tropical-looking Bogotá hotel conflicts with the city’s altitude and climate.
  • Brief remnants of the deleted bosses’ storyline leave the agencies, assignments, and moral stakes underexplained.
  • Jane identifying John from his urinating stance is questioned, with the leg kick offered as the identifying detail.
  • The agencies discovering the marriage only after six years strains belief; deep cover is suggested but questioned given the couple’s ordinary social life.
  • The I-Team’s nightly meal deliveries supposedly never crossed paths with John coming home at seven.
  • The $400,000 bounty per person seems low relative to the destruction and the couple’s expensive lifestyle.
  • Both spouses secretly building separate weapons storage into the house seems implausible, though it works as a metaphor for marital noncommunication.
Mr. and Mrs. Smith poster
Mr. and Mrs. Smith

Sequel, Prequel, Limited Series, or All-Black Remake

All-Black cast; Glover–Erskine series; unrealized Pitt–Jolie sequel

In the discussion (3)
Approx. transcript time · 01:31:57Read transcript
  • An all-Black cast is welcomed as a possibility.
  • The planned Amazon version with Donald Glover is discussed: Phoebe Waller-Bridge departed, and Maya Erskine is identified as her replacement after an initial claim of limbo.
  • Jolie reportedly said in 2010 that she and Pitt wanted a sequel but could not find a story; a sequel is considered potentially good for their careers.
Mr. and Mrs. Smith poster
Mr. and Mrs. Smith

Probably Unanswerable Questions

Weapons-stove installation; unequal agency resources

In the discussion (2)
Approx. transcript time · 01:34:25Read transcript
  • Who can install a weapons stove, how complicated is the work, and how much would it cost?
  • The contrast between Jane’s skyscraper team and John’s shabby garage raises the question of agency status; her greater kill count and resources support her being the more successful assassin.
In the discussion (3)
Approx. transcript time · 01:36:06Read transcript
  • Duplicity is selected for its spy-couple premise, chemistry, and ideas, despite a wish that its execution worked better.
  • Grosse Pointe Blank is selected.
  • By the Sea is selected to follow the couple’s relationship from its exciting beginning to sadness.
Displaying discussions 5029 - 5040 of 8676 in total