Foley's first inspection is nominated for its insulting exchanges, tattoo reaction and immediate establishment of the character.
The first obstacle course is nominated, contrasting Mayo's selfish excellence with Seeger's struggle and room to improve.
Mayo and Paula meeting is nominated for immediate chemistry despite the dated ethnic language.
The bar fight is nominated for the payoff when an aggressive local ignores Mayo's reluctance and is beaten; the trope of hostility to servicemen is questioned and partly defended through post-Vietnam context.
Caruso's near-drowning and Foley's rescue are nominated, with attention to Caruso's youthful appearance.
Foley demanding Mayo's resignation and the ensuing punishment culminating in I got nowhere else to go is the favored scene, receiving explicit agreement.
Paula trying to make Mayo jealous at the bar is a second-favorite scene, especially the use of Tunnel of Love; the apparent long separation conflicts with the few days actually elapsed.
The second obstacle course is nominated for Mayo sacrificing a record to help Seeger, completing his shift from selfish standout to teammate.
Worley's altitude-chamber panic is praised as part of convincing training sequences that invite viewers to imagine enduring the tests.
Mayo and Paula confronting Lynette while searching for Sid is praised as powerful rather than comfortably rewatchable; Sid swallowing the ring is similarly intense and alarming.
Mayo fighting Foley in the hangar is enjoyed as a sudden martial-arts-film detour, while the lack of military oversight is questioned.
The assignment ceremony and Mayo's farewell to Foley are praised as an Oscar-worthy sequence, especially Foley's restrained reaction.
The factory rescue ending is praised, while Lynette's cheerful reaction remains uncomfortable after her role in Sid's fate.
Final scene choices favor the long-weekend DOR punishment with agreement, while another choice is the Tunnel of Love bar encounter for its depiction of formerly intimate people reconnecting.
The sex scene is praised as unusually beautiful and convincing; reported edits to avoid an X rating and Winger's dissatisfaction are noted.
Paula and Lynette smoking, dressing for the weekend and listening to Pat Benatar are aged-best choices; the setting's rural presentation is debated as a frontier-like Navy town.
Paula and Lynette are aged-best character choices; Lynette's shack with carefully kept plants is praised, while her dated haircut is deferred to aged-worst.
Caruso's appearance with a crew cut is an aged-best choice.
DOR as a reusable life concept and obstacle-course scenes are aged-best choices.
Foley's warning about the Puget Debs is an aged-best choice, with the term explained as sarcastic debutantes.
Hair-shaving scenes are an aged-best choice, compared with Stripes and Full Metal Jacket.
Sid swallowing the ring and Treat Me Right are recalled as enduring details; politically incorrect marching songs are considered both aged-best and aged-worst.
Opening and closing credits and the factory rescue ending are aged-best choices.
Grace Zabriskie's mother is praised; the silent stepfather is read as resenting reminders of his wife's earlier pilot relationship.
Water-submersion training is praised as unusual film material, although the category is qualified as scenes rarely seen now rather than something literally aging well.
Tunnel of Love is the clear needle-drop choice, with Treat Me Right a strong runner-up; Joe Cocker’s song is excluded because it plays over the closing credits.
A proposed awards principle would exclude songs heard only over credits, while integrating a song into the score is admired.
No weak performance or boring section is identified; even a pee break is difficult, though repeated obstacle courses might be skippable for some viewers.
The abruptness of Sid's late arc is proposed as a possible weak link after the initial inability to name one.
The opening scene's editing, visible Gossett fight double and Lynette's haircut are aged-worst choices.
Don Simpson reportedly wanted Up Where We Belong removed in favor of On the Wings of Love, a judgment considered badly wrong after the song's success.
Lynette rejecting Sid is considered brutally painful; the compressed sequence from pregnancy worry to panic, proposal, rejection and suicide suggests missing development, though family pressure and his brother's death provide context.
The abruptness of Sid's late arc is proposed as a possible weak link after the initial inability to name one.
An earlier script reportedly gave Mayo's father a larger role and a visit during training, prompting a hypothetical appearance at graduation.
Byron Mayo is jokingly proposed as an addition to the Wayne Jenkins impression category, built around the disturbing opening encounter.
Mayo's side-business margins are questioned as too small for the risk, and Paula's teenage sister openly flirting at dinner is considered especially dated.
Trying to secure a future through pregnancy with a pilot is criticized as an implausible life strategy, while Lynette's desire to escape to Hawaii is acknowledged.
Displaying discussions 5041 - 5052 of 8676 in total
