Categories & segments

American Pie The Rewatchables
In the discussion (4)
Approx. transcript time · 00:58:55Read transcript
  • Casey Affleck brief sushi-bar/cellphone scene initially sole nominee; availability/friendship speculation not fact.
  • Jennifer Coolidge single scene favorite counterproposal.
  • Stifler little brother nominated; compared with host son comic energy.
  • Affleck vote, Coolidge vote and agreement that Coolidge wins; brief cameo versus heat-check distinction debated.
American Pie The Rewatchables
American Pie poster
American Pie

Half-Assed Internet Research

Ratings cuts, franchise spinoffs, Long Beach locations, practical props, sports preparation and improvisation anecdotes.

In the discussion (6)
Approx. transcript time · 01:01:38Read transcript
  • Reported four attempts to obtain R rather than NC 17 rating.
  • Four main films and four 2005–2009 directDVD spinoffs reported; Band Camp, Naked Mile, garbled third title, and Book of Love enumerated; no viewing claimed.
  • Reported Long Beach filming and practical prop anecdotes, Costco pie and egg-white drink effect.
  • Klein and Scott reportedly practiced lacrosse three weeks, body doubles handled sports despite convincing appearance.
  • YM Katie Holmes cover seen with Klein, subsequent relationship recalled.
  • Hannigan line reportedly improvised and retained.
American Pie The Rewatchables
In the discussion (4)
Approx. transcript time · 01:05:03Read transcript
  • Many cast career peaks proposed here; Coolidge and Levy rejected with Best in Show, SCTV alternatives and Schitts Creek question; Scott later 15 million third-film payday preferred.
  • Tara Reid affirmative; Biggs considered with Loser alternative, his performance defended.
  • Klein Election probably apex, better character positioning than American Pie despite similar persona.
  • Casey Affleck mentioned as a possible exception in the introductory apex reasoning; no clear settled career-peak judgment follows.
American Pie The Rewatchables
American Pie poster
American Pie

Picking Nits

Sanitized aftermath, implausible streaming, private bedrooms at a crowded party and Finch rumor mechanics questioned; rumor mechanism corrected.

In the discussion (5)
Approx. transcript time · 01:11:09Read transcript
  • Physical aftermath of sexual scene judged implausibly sanitized; ratings/budget jokes offered.
  • 1999 streaming quality implausibly good, even 2009 comparison.
  • Large party but protagonists monopolize bedrooms without interruption or other guests.
  • Finch rumor campaign mechanics questioned then corrected: Jessica paid 200 to spread stories; questioner missed explanation.
  • Finch putting-green and bathroom routine considered bizarre, another relates.
American Pie The Rewatchables
American Pie poster
American Pie

The Neil McCauley “A Book about Metals” Award for Best Line from the Movie

No single selection: Sherman’s introduction, the band-camp reveal, the computer metaphor, and Stifler lines

In the discussion (4)
Approx. transcript time · 01:13:37Read transcript
  • Sherman boy-to-man introduction praised.
  • Bandcamp reveal line praised for surprise, retained here as non-graphic description.
  • Computer-mouse euphemism praised and retrospectively most 1999 candidate; Leon delivery noted.
  • Stifler introductory exhortation and abrupt insult recalled; homophobic material condemned as dated.
American Pie The Rewatchables
American Pie poster
American Pie

Who Won the Movie?

No consensus: Scott, Levy, and the Weitz brothers; Affleck also advocated

In the discussion (4)
Approx. transcript time · 01:17:30Read transcript
  • Casey Affleck preference defended for brief sushi cameo; MILFs worldwide joking collective suggestion.
  • White’s brothers proposed based on subsequent career; Hannigan / Leon career praise but Bill explicitly rejects Leon winner/performance.
  • Scott short-term and Levy long-term proposed, Levy and White’s brothers another combined formulation; Biggs newly bankable visibility considered.
  • Final Scott short-term / Levy long-term reiterated with agreement, another sticks with White’s brothers; no single unanimous winner.
Mr. and Mrs. Smith poster
Mr. and Mrs. Smith

Half-Assed Internet Research

Budget and gross; knife skills; expanded Vaughn role; therapy premise; Bogotá objections; Fight Club shirt; reused helicopter shot; 50 drafts; TV pilot and sequel ideas

In the discussion (10)
Approx. transcript time · 00:02:49Read transcript
  • The stated budget is $110 million, possibly more, against a $487 million gross.
  • Jolie reportedly brought knife skills and her own collection to the production.
  • Vaughn’s Eddie reportedly expanded from a cameo-sized part.
  • Kinberg reportedly developed the premise after friends described marriage therapy as aggressive and mercenary.
  • Colombians and their president reportedly objected to the film’s depiction of the country.
  • Brody wears a Fight Club T-shirt during the interrogation.
  • A helicopter shot over Bogotá was taken from Clear and Present Danger and modified with CGI.
  • The script reportedly went through 50 drafts, with writers including Terence Winter, Akiva Goldsman, and Carrie Fisher.
  • A 2007 ABC pilot written by Kinberg and directed by Liman starred Jordana Brewster and Martin Henderson; it was pitched as Married with Children with guns and was not picked up.
  • Subsequent sequel ideas are described as eventually becoming Keeping Up with the Joneses, with uncertainty about whether Pitt and Jolie would have participated.
Mr. and Mrs. Smith poster
Mr. and Mrs. Smith

The Stephen A. Smith Hottest Take Award

Aniston benefited; leads too beautiful to be erotic; ugly kitchen tiles; divorced-spies sequel

In the discussion (5)
Approx. transcript time · 00:25:59Read transcript
  • The triangle is proposed as a long-term career benefit for Aniston because it sustained public attention and sympathy.
  • The leads may be so extraordinarily attractive that their chemistry feels less relatable and less erotic; Original Sin is compared to watching beautiful otherworldly figures.
  • The kitchen tiles are called exceptionally ugly, beyond the much-discussed curtains.
  • A sequel starring Pitt and Jolie as divorced spies is proposed, while the ugliness of their split is acknowledged as a major obstacle.
  • The divorced-spies sequel could use different actors; one version ends in death or divorce, while another imagines a comedy of remarriage.
Displaying discussions 5005 - 5016 of 8676 in total