Categories & segments

In the discussion (3)
Approx. transcript time · 01:19:50Read transcript
  • Cruise is initially outvoted 2–1 by Hanks supporters; the debate weighs unlikeability against comedy and the interest of casting Hanks against type.
  • Craig chooses Cruise, citing Hanks’s underlying lovability; Collateral and early Jerry Maguire illustrate the alternative.
  • A recent Jerry Maguire rewatch prompts a Hanks voter to switch to Cruise, making the final result 3–1.
The War of the Roses poster
The War of the Roses

Picking Nits

Revenge date; media silence; fatal fall; chandelier; neighbors; happy marriage; vehicle; dog breed

In the discussion (9)
Approx. transcript time · 01:24:14Read transcript
  • A revenge-date/sex scene for Barbara is wanted instead of framing scenes; possible divorce consequences and the existing Gavin attempt complicate it.
  • Keeping two deaths at a mansion out of newspapers seems impossible, particularly with a food critic already involved.
  • The drop height, delayed simultaneous deaths and surviving movement are questioned, while the ending’s dramatic perfection is defended.
  • The chandelier improbably supports both people before pulverizing; Oliver should release it before being pulled over.
  • Neighbors never intervene despite vehicular violence, repeated fires and boarded windows; self-absorption and bystander assumptions are offered as defenses.
  • One more happy-couple scene is desired to justify the long marriage.
  • The abrupt transition from passionate night to marriage lacks evidence of a happy life, though an unconsidered relationship may be the point.
  • Barbara’s oversized vehicle seems excessive for 1989 and modest catering earnings, but is defended as visual characterization of money and power.
  • Oliver’s dog should have been a dull white Labrador or unpleasant poodle rather than a personable golden retriever, prompting a bad-poodle anecdote.
The War of the Roses poster
The War of the Roses

Probably Unanswerable Questions

Children; will; ruined house; Benny’s future

In the discussion (2)
Approx. transcript time · 01:35:21Read transcript
  • The children’s immediate aftermath, wills, damaged house and future sale are questioned; another doomed owner would create a domestic Amityville/Shining sequel.
  • Benny’s possible new loving home is hoped for, against the joke that the survival shot was merely inserted.
In the discussion (3)
Approx. transcript time · 01:36:13Read transcript
  • Body Heat and Fatal Attraction are proposed together as a triple feature showing both leads in erotic thrillers.
  • Romancing the Stone is another choice for the happier end of their partnership.
  • Mr. & Mrs. Smith offers similar house destruction with a happier fictional outcome.
The War of the Roses poster
The War of the Roses

Producer review

Deranged, imperfect fun; fatal ending preferred to framing epilogue

In the discussion (2)
Approx. transcript time · 01:39:47Read transcript
  • A first viewing is enthusiastically praised as deranged, imperfect and freer than contemporary market-tested movies; the strange framing background adds a fairy-tale quality.
  • The fatal ending is praised but the return to DeVito’s office is criticized; the viewer paused to invite a partner and would have restarted the film.
Displaying discussions 4429 - 4440 of 7108 in total