Categories & segments

Escape From New York The Rewatchables
Escape From New York poster
Escape From New York

What’s Aged the Best?

Frank Doubleday’s Romero, the score, deleted material, fatal catchphrase, military base, Kurt Russell, and soundtrack lead the praise.

In the discussion (8)
Approx. transcript time · 00:40:18Read transcript
  • Romero is praised as perfectly balanced between an extreme look and an ordinary accountant-like voice.
  • His first-line physical flourish and the finger exchange remain memorable.
  • The deleted bank-robbery opening is valued as an extra seven minutes for fans.
  • Every character who tells Snake they heard he was dead eventually dies, creating a recurring kiss-of-death phrase.
  • The Gulf Fire plane and the Duke’s car are added to the list of designs that still hold up.
  • Hawk’s military installation and its sweeping helicopter-preparation shots remain an unimproved dystopian base design.
  • Kurt Russell’s Snake performance is judged capable of making him a star even if released today.
  • The synth score remains futuristic, frightening, and musically influential.
Escape From New York The Rewatchables
Escape From New York poster
Escape From New York

What’s Aged the Worst?

Post-2001 imagery, the president, romance beat, tattoo, huge phone, fight sounds, and inert radar display are criticized.

In the discussion (8)
Approx. transcript time · 00:45:16Read transcript
  • A presidential aircraft flying toward a New York skyscraper plays differently after 2001.
  • Donald Pleasence is judged an implausible American president because of his accent and shifty Nixon-like manner.
  • A possible sexual pause with the Chock Full o’ Nuts woman is debated as either unappealing or understandable given Snake’s isolation and limited time.
  • Snake’s tattoo is criticized as hastily designed, though its roughness is defended as period-appropriate.
  • Hawk’s future cell phone is comically enormous.
  • The exaggerated fist-fight sound effects have dated.
  • The radar operator claims Snake entered a building even though the screen’s blinking light does not move.
  • The appended interview says the president’s foreign accent was intentional because the story is set in the future, directly qualifying the panel’s accent criticism.
Escape From New York The Rewatchables
Escape From New York poster
Escape From New York

The Ruffalo / Hanna / Rubinek / Partridge Overacting Award

Frank Doubleday wins the overacting category, with Ernest Borgnine, Harry Dean Stanton, and Donald Pleasence as alternatives.

In the discussion (3)
Approx. transcript time · 00:51:58Read transcript
Escape From New York The Rewatchables
Escape From New York poster
Escape From New York

The Dion Waiters Award for Best Heat Check Performance

Frank Doubleday completes the triple crown over Adrian Barbeau, Isaac Hayes, and Ernest Borgnine.

In the discussion (3)
Approx. transcript time · 00:51:58Read transcript
  • Adrian Barbeau and Isaac Hayes are strong short-performance alternatives.
  • Ernest Borgnine is praised as a famous older actor enjoying the role.
  • Doubleday wins for moving from terror to insecurity, dying with strange physical precision, and adding expressive gestures throughout.
Escape From New York The Rewatchables
Escape From New York poster
Escape From New York

Half-Assed Internet Research

Research covers narration, location work, the eye patch, Maggie’s death insert, James Cameron, Nick Castle, and Stephen Ford.

In the discussion (9)
Approx. transcript time · 00:55:13Read transcript
  • Jamie Lee Curtis is identified as the narrator.
  • Russell reportedly stayed in character but removed the eye patch between takes because it damaged his depth perception.
  • East St. Louis was selected for its old buildings, river, bridge, and blocks of fire-damaged rubble.
  • The Chain of Rocks Bridge was reportedly purchased for one dollar, and the city darkened ten blocks nightly for filming.
  • An eleven-year-old J. J. Abrams reportedly prompted the insert proving Maggie died, which Carpenter shot with Adrian Barbeau in their garage.
  • James Cameron worked on visual effects and cinematography before The Terminator and was considered the set genius.
  • Co-writer Nick Castle also played Michael Myers in Halloween.
  • Gerald Ford’s son Stephen Ford plays the Secret Service agent at the cockpit.
  • The appended interview says Snake’s eye patch was proposed as a visible, painful war injury and might also have a hidden futuristic function.
Escape From New York The Rewatchables
Escape From New York poster
Escape From New York

Apex Mountain

Ox Baker, John Carpenter for Halloween, dystopian New York movies, and possibly Escape from L.A.’s production receive positive cases; Kurt Russell remains debated.

In the discussion (8)
Approx. transcript time · 00:58:03Read transcript
  • Kurt Russell is debated between this breakout and later peaks around Tango & Cash, Backdraft, Tombstone, and other roles.
  • Escape from New York is treated as the moment Russell became the guy even if it was not his biggest-star phase.
  • Making Escape from L.A. is floated as a possible Russell apex because he had enough power to revive the character.
  • Ox Baker receives a yes.
  • Adrian Barbeau is rejected in favor of her years on Maude.
  • John Carpenter receives Halloween as his apex.
  • The year 1997 is rejected as a cultural apex.
  • Dystopian New York films receive a clear apex verdict here.
Escape From New York The Rewatchables
Escape From New York poster
Escape From New York

Picking Nits

The unique fusion tape, terrorist flight attendants, Brain’s competence, escape pod, arena security, capsules, day–night timing, and Cabby trade are questioned.

In the discussion (9)
Approx. transcript time · 01:00:14Read transcript
  • The president carries the only copy of a nuclear-fusion peace tape on a dangerous flight, with no backup.
  • Terrorist flight attendants apparently pass background checks and seize the aircraft.
  • Brain can make gasoline but struggles to locate an obvious tall-building landing point and delivers Snake into immediate capture.
  • The one-person escape pod leaves the president easy to seize and excludes Secret Service protection.
  • After the gladiator fight, guards inexplicably stop treating Snake as dangerous.
  • Romero is unfairly excluded from watching the fight.
  • The implanted charges dissolve and explode with implausible second-by-second precision.
  • The changing daylight seems inconsistent with the stated 24-hour mission.
  • Cabby’s casual hat-for-tape barter with Romero leaves the negotiation unexplained.
Escape From New York The Rewatchables
Escape From New York poster
Escape From New York

The Neil McCauley “A Book about Metals” Award for Best Line from the Movie

Snake’s death-rumor line, Romero’s countdown, Hawk exchange, and the Duke slogan lead the quotes.

In the discussion (5)
Approx. transcript time · 01:07:28Read transcript
  • The first Hawk–Snake scene is treated as quotable line by line.
  • Snake Plissken, I thought you were dead is a primary takeaway.
  • Romero’s touch-me countdown is another favorite.
  • Snake telling Hawk the president is dead and may have been eaten is singled out.
  • The Duke of New York, A number one is selected as the favorite line and a family affirmation.
Escape From New York The Rewatchables
Escape From New York poster
Escape From New York

Sequel, Prequel, Limited Series, or All-Black Remake

A modern series is watchable but risks losing the handmade magic; Catalina and an inverted Escape to New York are proposed.

In the discussion (3)
Approx. transcript time · 01:08:34Read transcript
  • A 2020 series offers many advantages, but modern effects may erase the practical magic that distinguishes the original from Escape from L.A.
  • Catalina Island is proposed as a California prison society for a series.
  • Escape to New York would invert the premise by making Manhattan the only safe, supplied area in a ruined country.
Escape From New York The Rewatchables
Escape From New York poster
Escape From New York

Probably Unanswerable Questions

Questions cover World War III, the liberation front, survival strategy, prison services, and the displaced people and sports teams of New York.

In the discussion (6)
Approx. transcript time · 01:05:35Read transcript
  • The panel asks what happened in World War III and infers the United States probably lost.
  • The National Liberation Front’s plans after crashing the plane and then losing the president remain unclear.
  • A hypothetical prisoner chooses the sewers or immediate cremation in real life, but imagines overthrowing the Duke in a movie version.
  • Another participant imagines building a pirate radio station funded by Chock Full o’ Nuts.
  • The prison’s electricity, plumbing, food, entertainment, gas, and the Duke’s governing services are questioned.
  • The fate of New York’s teams, residents, homes, and largest arena is explored without a firm answer.
Escape From New York The Rewatchables
Escape From New York poster
Escape From New York

Who Won the Movie?

Kurt Russell wins, with Romero and John Carpenter also receiving major credit.

In the discussion (3)
Approx. transcript time · 01:16:11Read transcript
  • Kurt Russell is the immediate winner.
  • Romero and Carpenter are also credited with major wins.
  • The film is credited with setting up many later action movies.
Podcast choices
Speaker not identified
Kurt Russell
Speaker not identified
Kurt Russell
Displaying discussions 3433 - 3444 of 3876 in total