The opening helicopter imagery and its theatrical impact are praised; old square television framing diminished it. — Bill Simmons
Jack’s anger at Wendy’s writing interruption is nominated, with her hurt and the warning signs of their marriage discussed.
Jack’s drink with Lloyd is praised for Nicholson’s expressive face and commitment.
The manuscript discovery and stair confrontation are praised for both performances, staging, terror and the revelation of the repeated sentence.
The manuscript’s typing is recounted, with the teardrop-shaped page and quoted indentation singled out. — Bill Simmons
The panel debates how many pages Wendy needs to inspect before understanding the manuscript. — Bill Simmons
The axe-through-the-bathroom-door sequence is nominated as an outstanding horror scene.
The iconic bathroom attack is admired, but prior exposure to parodies diluted its terror for one viewer; Jack abandoning the attack prompts a question. — Sean Fennessey
The killing of Scatman Crothers is praised as shocking: Nicholson is hidden behind a pillar and the long return suggests a larger role. — Bill Simmons
Danny’s maze escape is praised for his preparation and retracing of footprints. — Bill Simmons
The second Gold Room visit and Grady conversation are added, along with the introductory hotel tour. — Chris Ryan
The ice-cream conversation is praised for explicitly acknowledging the supernatural power. — Sean Fennessey
The manuscript discovery and staircase scene receive the final selection. — Bill Simmons
