Split between Kim being taken and the dinner at Jean-Claude’s house
In the discussion (3)
- Kim being taken through the phone-call instructions is one preferred scene
- The dinner at Jean-Claude’s house became the other preferred scene after repeated viewings
- The apartment raid and the extended ending are also named among five top-tier scenes
Liam Neeson’s action-star reinvention and the phone speech lead several praised elements
In the discussion (4)
- The film knowing exactly what it is is praised
- Liam Neeson’s filmography is said to have been reinterpreted after the role made him an action star
- The phone speech is proposed as the best individual element but challenged because it was already perfect on release
- Jean-Claude’s behind-a-desk decline is praised as a recurring thematic joke
Foreign-villain stereotyping and the U2 premise lead a larger set of objections
In the discussion (5)
- The film’s portrayal of nearly every foreign character as murderous or complicit is the strongest objection
- Teenagers following U2 around Europe in 2008 is criticized as implausible
- Bryan’s drinks-with-his-buddies scene is criticized as awkward
- Kim’s rapid recovery without visible trauma is criticized
- Taken 3 is rejected while Taken 2 receives a qualified defense
Marco, Jean-Claude, Jean-Claude’s wife, the club manager, the sheik, and Marco’s table are nominated
In the discussion (2)
- Marco, Jean-Claude, Jean-Claude’s wife, the club manager, and the sheik are nominated
- The men at Marco’s table are added for enthusiastically backing him
Liam Neeson; Maggie Grace and the Albanian traffickers are also discussed
In the discussion (3)
- Liam Neeson is treated as an unequivocal apex because the role made him an action star in his mid-fifties
- Maggie Grace is judged permanently identified with the daughter role
- The Albanian traffickers are jokingly assigned an apex as screen villains
Steve Buscemi as the auction manager
In the discussion (1)
- Steve Buscemi is independently chosen by both participants for the auction-manager role
The sex-trafficking club manager
In the discussion (2)
- The club manager’s wounded appeal that it was only business is selected as overacting
- An overacting performance in Alive is raised as a possible namesake for the category
An unnamed sole winner, credited with reviving action movies
In the discussion (1)
- An unnamed sole winner is said to win the film and action movies while reviving the form