Rewatch Vault
Movies Categories People Resources
‹ Back to Tin Cup Browse The Butch’s Girlfriend Award for the Weakest Link in the Film
Tin Cup · The Rewatchables ·September 16, 2025
Tin Cup poster
Tin Cup

The Butch’s Girlfriend Award for the Weakest Link in the Film

Unclear lesson; stripper subplot; inconsistent Roy characterization; excessive shanks; unnecessary epilogue

In the discussion (6)
Approx. transcript time · 01:07:14Read transcript
  • Lack of a lesson is a weak-link objection; never laying up, immortality and possible endorsements offer counters.
  • The stripper/deed subplot could be cut; the older former partner seems implausible, with ex-wife corrected to ex-girlfriend.
  • Roy alternates inconsistently between eloquent philosopher and someone confused by ordinary vocabulary.
  • A professional could get the shanks, but Roy's repeated extreme shanks without a fix are excessive.
  • The film should end on Nice par, David; closing the stripper plot adds five unnecessary minutes, and a possible sequel could already be set up through next year's Open.
  • A contractual or bet-driven tango scene is joking speculation.
rewatchvault.com

An independent archive of The Rewatchables.

Guides & Resources

hello@rewatchvault.com

Made with ♥ in NYC

NOW LISTENINGThe Rewatchables

Debug
Envproduction
Ruby3.3.10
Rails8.1.3.1
DBrewatchvault
Routearchive/discussions#show