Most Rewatchable Scene
Final reveal: there never was an Aaron
In the discussion (15)
Approx. transcript time · 00:36:16Read transcript
- The opening credits and banquet effectively establish the film, including Norton in the boys’ choir.
- Linney’s first cigarette and the six-month one-night-stand line establish the former relationship.
- The opening banquet establishes Vail’s arrogance and expectation that the former lover will come home with him.
- The post-murder chase and train crossing are effective; jumping aboard the train is proposed as an escape, then questioned because Aaron may want to be caught.
- The recurring Gere–Linney exchanges are admired as a group.
- Vail briefing Tommy and Naomi works as a classic legal-team scene, especially his distinction between stealing the ring and possessing it.
- The recurring McDormand interviews are praised, especially Norton’s momentary face change when she rattles him.
- Finding the sex tape is nominated.
- Linney’s late-night bar negotiation with Vail is the preferred encounter between them and signals her strength as a performer.
- Aaron’s transformation into Roy is a major moment.
- Braugher on the stand and his tense confrontation with Vail are nominated.
- Vail provoking Mahoney on the stand over South River, using Pinero’s death as his reason to go rogue, is a favorite.
- Shaughnessy eating Chinese food while explaining how the city works is another Mahoney highlight.
- Aaron/Roy choking the prosecutor on the stand remains effective even when the transformation is anticipated.
- The final revelation that Aaron never existed is the chosen scene; the delayed neck apology overturns the apparent resolution.