Picking Nits
Chemistry; escalator continuity; travel timing; absent parents; clothes; collision; bathroom recognition
In the discussion (8)
Approx. transcript time · 00:19:53Read transcript
- Phillippe’s charisma and chemistry with Witherspoon are disputed; the claim that off-screen romance impairs screen chemistry is countered with Pitt/Jolie and Cruise/Kidman.
- The escalator appears stationary for the first steps and moving after the camera angle changes, suggesting stitched takes.
- Penn Station is considered implausibly romantic, with its actual escalators imagined as obstructed rather than a setting for reconciliation.
- The Penn Station reunion’s timing and Sebastian’s rapid arrival from the Queensboro Bridge seem implausible.
- Absent parents seem especially implausible for Annette, whose father is a headmaster, even if wealthy city teenagers might have inattentive traveling parents.
- The man discovered in the trundle bed walks into the house in his underwear, prompting questions about retrieving his clothes and encountering servants; the spoken actor name is inconsistent.
- Sebastian’s fatal collision is criticized as staged and physically unconvincing; the participants think the impact might be survivable and that he had room to avoid it.
- Annette and Kathryn pretending not to recognize each other in the bathroom is challenged, with uncertainty about funeral attendance; others defend the behavior as a social power play.