Categories & segments

Manchester by the Sea poster
Manchester by the Sea

The Slow Ride / Kid Cudi – Pursuit of Happiness Award for Best Needle Drop

Stentorian’s garage song; Bob Dylan’s “Lily, Rosemary and the Jack of Hearts.”

In the discussion (3)
Approx. transcript time · 00:58:25Read transcript
  • Stentorian’s first garage song is nominated even while the band is mocked.
  • For Rock Bottom Month, the award is jokingly reframed as whether adding “Pursuit of Happiness” would improve or worsen the movie.
  • “Lily, Rosemary and the Jack of Hearts” is also called a very good needle drop.
Manchester by the Sea poster
Manchester by the Sea

The Great Shot Gordo Award for Most Cinematic Shot

The final backs-to-camera shot; hill and ball; hill encounter; crowded bar fight.

In the discussion (2)
Approx. transcript time · 00:58:58Read transcript
  • The last backs-to-camera shot and the hill with the lost ball are selected.
  • The slanted hill composition places one character lower, while two-shots and the crowded bar fight are praised as efficient and painterly.
In the discussion (2)
Approx. transcript time · 01:00:25Read transcript
  • A laudatory review is described as devoting its final section to race, white male characters and white working-class withdrawal.
  • The interpretation is called interesting but invented, and the setting is defended as a place with very few Black residents.
Manchester by the Sea poster
Manchester by the Sea

What’s Aged the Worst?

Off-screen controversy; emotional aftermath; double polo shirts; criticism of the classical cue; the unfilmed whale-watching ending.

In the discussion (6)
Approx. transcript time · 01:05:06Read transcript
  • Affleck’s off-screen controversy is said to have overshadowed the performance.
  • Trying to do anything social after watching the film remains difficult even on later viewings.
  • Tate Donovan wearing two polos is called outrageous.
  • Contemporary complaints that the Adagio in G minor was overused are themselves criticized because the older film examples were decades earlier.
  • Damon reports that a planned joyful family whale-watching flashback required difficult boat, whale and drone photography and was not filmed after the production ran out of money.
  • Damon is jokingly blamed for not contributing his own money to preserve the unfilmed ending.
Manchester by the Sea poster
Manchester by the Sea

The Stephen A. Smith Hottest Take Award

The wife shares half the blame; a great four-film career is enough.

In the discussion (4)
Approx. transcript time · 01:08:23Read transcript
  • A reader’s proposed rename commemorating the Luke Wilson and Harrison Ford comparison is enthusiastically accepted.
  • The hottest take assigns the wife half the blame because of the heat, fireplace screen and escape circumstances, while still acknowledging the husband is not blameless.
  • The opposing response emphasizes intoxication, drugs and a late-night alcohol trip before the blame discussion moves on.
  • A lower-stakes take argues that a genius ending with only four movies can still have an excellent career.
In the discussion (5)
Approx. transcript time · 01:11:22Read transcript
  • After Damon could not play the lead, the role was steered to Affleck; using Damon as the brother is proposed as an improvement.
  • Chalamet reportedly auditioned for Patrick and did not get the role.
  • Hedges is preferred to Chalamet for frame, class background and Massachusetts credibility, despite both actors’ New York backgrounds.
  • Krasinski is reported as connected to the original idea and initially floated for the role before Lonergan completed the film.
  • Krasinski remains an uncertain dramatic fit because this kind of acting had not been seen from him, though A Quiet Place is offered as reason not to rule him out; Affleck’s Gone Baby Gone work supplies a contrasting precedent.
Manchester by the Sea poster
Manchester by the Sea

Recasting Couch

Damon or Ben Affleck in supporting roles; J. Smith-Cameron in several smaller roles.

In the discussion (3)
Approx. transcript time · 01:11:41Read transcript
  • Damon is proposed for the older brother or the Broderick part, and Ben Affleck for the older brother; celebrity distraction is the main objection.
  • Ben Affleck is also jokingly imagined as the stranger confronted at the bar.
  • The director’s wife is proposed for the angry local woman, the friend’s wife or Sandy’s mother.
Manchester by the Sea poster
Manchester by the Sea

Is This Movie Better With…?

Chris from The Town, Vincent Hanna or Sergeant Dignam.

In the discussion (13)
Approx. transcript time · 01:14:55Read transcript
  • Thanos is jokingly offered while the hosts test-drive the add-one-character category; he is not accepted as the result.
  • Chris from The Town is imagined meeting Lee at a bar.
  • Vincent Hanna is imagined conducting the police interview.
  • Wayne Jenkins is retained as a named candidate in the recurring better-with prompt.
  • “Danny Treo” is retained exactly as rendered by the machine transcript as a named candidate; the possible identity is not independently normalized.
  • Sam Jackson is retained as a named candidate in the recurring better-with prompt.
  • J. T. Walsh is retained as a named candidate in the recurring better-with prompt.
  • Byron Mayo is retained exactly as rendered by the machine transcript as a candidate; the identity is not independently normalized.
  • Harley Mays is retained exactly as rendered by the machine transcript as a candidate; the identity is not independently normalized.
  • The machine transcript renders another entry as “evil laughing, Ramon Raymond”; that uncertain candidate wording is preserved without inferring an identity.
  • “Philip Bakerall” is retained exactly as rendered by the machine transcript as a named candidate; the possible identity is not independently normalized.
  • Sergeant Dignam from The Departed is proposed as the hockey coach and enthusiastically accepted.
  • Chris from The Town is considered for addition to the recurring fictional-character pool.
In the discussion (3)
Approx. transcript time · 01:14:45Read transcript
  • Heather Burns is explicitly named as one of the speaker’s That Guys.
  • Wilson’s George is selected as the That Guy candidate.
  • The second Patrick girlfriend is considered, then redirected to heat check; her father and later movie appearance are discussed.
In the discussion (2)
Approx. transcript time · 01:15:53Read transcript
  • Anna Beresnikov and Gretchen Moff are candidates; Michelle Williams is judged too central despite limited screen time, and Matthew Broderick’s youth-pastor character is praised.
  • Lonergan’s brief on-screen parenting comment is proposed and accepted as the choice.
Displaying discussions 4477 - 4488 of 7108 in total