Categories & segments

Jaws 2 The Rewatchables
Jaws 2 poster
Jaws 2

The Stephen A. Smith Hottest Take Award

Mayor retaining office; Jackie’s influence on the trip; Jaws 2 ending New Hollywood

In the discussion (5)
Approx. transcript time · 00:57:16Read transcript
  • The mayor retaining office after the first film is called an extreme sequel contrivance; lawsuits and prosecution would be expected.
  • A counterfactual makes hero Brody mayor facing the same financial pressures. A dissent argues corrupt politicians often recover, especially when locals prioritize tourism income.
  • Even if reelected, the mayor’s repeated denial despite disappearances and a burned body strains credibility.
  • Jackie’s arrival fuels the boys’ risky sailing trip; a teen-only story might better explore rivalries and attraction. Boat-sex logistics remain doubtful.
  • Jaws 2’s financial success despite ordinary quality, rather than Jaws or Star Wars themselves, is blamed for ending New Hollywood and entrenching sequel economics.
Jaws 2 The Rewatchables
Jaws 2 poster
Jaws 2

Casting What-Ifs

Scheider’s Deer Hunter departure; Ricky Schroder replaced as Sean; Dreyfuss return discussion

In the discussion (3)
Approx. transcript time · 01:04:55Read transcript
  • Scheider’s departure from The Deer Hunter reportedly forced him into Jaws 2 under his Universal obligation; his fit for De Niro’s role is debated. Salary, points and a reportedly staged breakdown are discussed.
  • Ricky Schroder was replaced as Sean after the director change.
  • Dreyfuss’s proposed return becomes a joke about the novel’s affair; the affair is identified as novel material, not this film’s plot.
Jaws 2 The Rewatchables
Jaws 2 poster
Jaws 2

Apex Mountain

Child cast except Keith Gordon; water-skiing murders; water skiing (disputed)

In the discussion (10)
Approx. transcript time · 01:12:39Read transcript
  • No for Scheider.
  • No for sequels.
  • Lorraine Gary’s peak is Jaws: The Revenge.
  • Donna Wilkes’s peak is Angel.
  • The children except Keith Gordon probably reach their peak here.
  • Yes for water-skiing murders.
  • Water skiing in popular culture is proposed alongside Fonzie’s shark jump, then disputed.
  • No for sharks.
  • No for Murray Hamilton.
  • The poor making-of documentary is enjoyable, but no firm Apex judgment is made.
Jaws 2 The Rewatchables
Jaws 2 poster
Jaws 2

Cruise or Hanks?

Cruise

In the discussion (2)
Approx. transcript time · 01:15:10Read transcript
  • Young Cruise as Mike is proposed, then challenged because the category should recast Brody; Hanks is the conventional Brody choice.
  • Cruise becomes favored for Brody’s energy, running and unintentionally funny drunkenness, despite an objection to his drunk acting.
Displaying discussions 2149 - 2160 of 6801 in total