The Truman Show November 4, 2025 The Truman Show The father storyline; Marlon’s thin characterization; limited outside-world development. Read discussion ↗
Sneakers October 14, 2025 Sneakers The magical black box and Ben Kingsley’s performance divide the panel. Read discussion ↗
Jeremiah Johnson October 7, 2025 Jeremiah Johnson Jeremiah crossing the burial ground and surviving repeated severe injuries Read discussion ↗
The Sting September 30, 2025 The Sting The extra hitmen, absence of a substantial woman, sequel, racial slurs, and slow late stretch Read discussion ↗
Airplane! September 23, 2025 Airplane! One participant wants five more minutes of jokes, while another defends the short runtime and leaving the audience wanting more. Read discussion ↗
Tin Cup September 16, 2025 Tin Cup Unclear lesson; stripper subplot; inconsistent Roy characterization; excessive shanks; unnecessary epilogue Read discussion ↗
The Legend of Billie Jean September 9, 2025 The Legend of Billie Jean The abused-child rescue and bounty-seeking couple sequences are nominated. Read discussion ↗
American Gangster September 2, 2025 American Gangster The movie’s extensive historical fabrication Read discussion ↗
Witness August 26, 2025 Witness Rachel’s quick romantic transition; Book’s insufficient concern for Carter and Elaine Read discussion ↗
