Categories & segments

High Fidelity The Rewatchables
High Fidelity

Most Rewatchable Scene

The opening monologue, Marie DeSalle performance, Laura’s breakup reasons, record-store selling, Ian fantasies, Laura’s job list, the finale, and store arguments

In the discussion (13)
Approx. transcript time · 00:40:22Read transcript
  • The opening “music or misery” monologue and the line about being reached earlier are nominated.
  • Jack Black’s first entrance and the brief Charlie phone outburst are separate nominations. — Bill Simmons
  • The narration about a man being shot and betrayed by his girlfriend as Rob enters the club is nominated. — Bill Simmons
  • Laura telling Liz four reasons for the breakup is nominated, including Rob’s alarm that sleeping with someone else during Laura’s pregnancy counts as only the first reason. — Bill Simmons
  • Rob playing the Beta Band for store customers and watching for reactions is nominated as a record-selling scene. — Bill Simmons
  • Charlie returning Rob’s call before Ian arrives, followed by four imagined responses to Ian, is nominated. — Bill Simmons
  • Laura reading Rob’s private list of five dream jobs is nominated.
  • DJ Rob introducing Sonic Death Monkey and the final performance of “Let’s Get It On” are selected as the closing run. — Bill Simmons
  • The entire busy-Saturday hand-selling sequence is nominated for showing Rob, Barry, and Dick use three different selling styles. — Joanna Robinson
  • Seeing Marie DeSalle play, with everyone swooning together, is separately selected. — Rob Mahoney
  • Barry’s entrance ending with the Cosby-sweater insult is selected. — Chris Ryan
  • The Side One, Track One list argument and its Captain Beefheart dispute are selected.
  • The Tim Robbins fantasy ending with the patchouli-store insult is selected.
High Fidelity The Rewatchables
High Fidelity

The most 2000 thing

Work laptops left behind, directory assistance, Oakleys, mixtapes, answering machines, indoor smoking, Virgin Megastore anxiety, and the name Dick

In the discussion (9)
Approx. transcript time · 00:49:54Read transcript
  • Laura returning for the laptop she had left at work is selected. — Chris Ryan
  • Calling directory assistance to obtain a home address is selected.
  • Rob’s Oakley-style sunglasses are selected. — Joanna Robinson
  • The last days of mixtapes are selected. — Bill Simmons
  • Describing Marie through period pop-culture comparisons is selected. — Bill Simmons
  • Answering-machine anguish is selected. — Bill Simmons
  • Smoking inside the record store is debated as a period detail. — Chris Ryan
  • Fear of ending up at Virgin Megastore is selected. — Bill Simmons
  • A young adult named Dick is selected as a vanished period detail.
High Fidelity The Rewatchables
High Fidelity

What’s Aged the Best?

Mixtape craft, fourth-wall narration, vinyl, record-store labor, adult Charlie, relationship theories, Laura’s casting, cameos, the Hulu series, and Cusack’s oral-history confidence

In the discussion (14)
Approx. transcript time · 00:53:49Read transcript
  • Mixtapes are preferred to playlists because of the labor, sequencing, surprise, and physical presentation.
  • The sustained fourth-wall narration is praised, including moments when Laura nearly enters that private address. — Chris Ryan
  • Vinyl booming beyond expectations is praised. — Rob Mahoney
  • Thirty-something men discussing records, books, and movies is treated as enduring.
  • Record-store employees caring more about conversation than customers and declining unpaid risk are praised as durable workplace behavior. — Bill Simmons
  • Adult Charlie confronting Rob’s fantasy is praised.
  • The burn-out-versus-fade-away argument is praised.
  • Rob’s weight-class theory about dating Charlie is praised. — Bill Simmons
  • “Walking on Sunshine” and “sad bastard music” are praised separately. — Bill Simmons
  • Casting a European actress as Laura is praised because an American performer might feel too much like Rob’s mother.
  • Crowded, smoky coffeehouses and overqualified stars in cameos are praised.
  • The Hulu adaptation is praised as evidence that the premise lasts.
  • Cusack’s dominant tone in a 2020 oral history is praised and prompts a proposed oral-history heat-check award.
  • The discussion identifies this as possibly Cusack’s last great leading film after reviewing his career path. — Bill Simmons
High Fidelity The Rewatchables
High Fidelity

The Slow Ride / Kid Cudi – Pursuit of Happiness Award for Best Needle Drop

Stevie Wonder, Bob Dylan, the Beta Band, and Katrina and the Waves

In the discussion (4)
Approx. transcript time · 01:05:54Read transcript
  • Stevie Wonder’s closing song is nominated.
  • Bob Dylan after the funeral is nominated. — Rob Mahoney
  • The Beta Band’s “Dry the Rain” is selected, with an objection that the scene skips directly to the hook on CD.
  • Katrina and the Waves is selected as a pure needle drop. — Joanna Robinson
High Fidelity The Rewatchables
High Fidelity

The Butch’s Girlfriend Award for the Weakest Link in the Film

Disputed: Sarah’s painful realism; Rob ending with Laura

In the discussion (4)
Approx. transcript time · 01:08:31Read transcript
  • Lily Taylor’s character is nominated because her depression and breakup feel too real and sad for the surrounding comedy.
  • The defense argues that Sarah’s pain exposes the wreckage Rob ignores while interrogating his exes. — Chris Ryan
  • Rob ending with Laura is challenged in favor of the Chicago Reader critic or no partner.
  • The defense argues that choosing the exciting new critic would repeat Rob’s pattern, while returning to Laura expresses incremental growth.
High Fidelity The Rewatchables
High Fidelity

What’s Aged the Worst?

Rob’s response to assault, stalking, misogyny, hair continuity, the Springsteen cameo, and Fever Pitch consequences

In the discussion (5)
Approx. transcript time · 01:08:59Read transcript
  • Rob treating Penny’s account of sexual assault as reassurance about his own rejection is criticized. — Chris Ryan
  • Rob’s semi-stalking, mean-spiritedness, and misogyny are named as dated behavior. — Chris Ryan
  • Cusack’s hair changes visibly across scenes shot out of order. — Bill Simmons
  • Springsteen’s cameo is judged less effective than remembered, though the discussion supplies production and rights context.
  • The film’s success is jokingly blamed for the later Fever Pitch adaptation and its World Series access. — Bill Simmons
Displaying discussions 1573 - 1584 of 11315 in total