The 1969 prologue divides the panel: one participant would omit it, while the casting of the younger leads earns praise.
The supposed NSA agents confronting Marty is nominated.
The password-surveillance scene is nominated for Carl and Crease both wanting a look at the seduction.
Marty getting caught in the mathematician’s office is preferred to the preceding surveillance gag.
The Scrabble-code breakthrough is nominated.
Cosmo’s return and his financial-equality monologue are nominated.
Redford’s restrained reactions make an effective counterpoint to Kingsley’s large performance.
The discussion questions why the film treats Cosmo’s equality rhetoric as madness and compares its aging radicals with other films.
Reconstructing Marty’s journey through remembered sounds is selected for its suspense.
The sound deductions are enjoyed despite doubts about concussion and implausible memory; the apparent missing Bay Area bridge is defended geographically.
Cosmo addressing Marty over the intercom and revealing Liz as a hostage is nominated.
James Earl Jones’s surprise arrival gives the ending an extra burst of excitement.
The team’s requests for rewards make the final negotiation especially funny.
Praises the entire Warner Brandes operation, from identifying him to the restaurant ruse. — Kyle Brandt
Chooses the final fortress heist as his most rewatchable sequence. — Kyle Brandt
Chooses the cocktail-party sound reconstruction and also praises the simultaneous Scrabble decoding and box testing. — Joanna Robinson