Lin Shay as Elise is maybe the number one That Guy of all time for one participant. — Bill Simmons
She was Magda in There's Something About Mary, the heavily tanned friend with the dog, and was also in Kingpin; the match to this movie was a shock.
She was in Nightmare on Elm Street and is the sister of New Line's founder Bob Shay.
She is among the most recognizable female That Guys of the last 30 years, alongside Barbara Crampton; like Margot Martindale she became a name, here through the Insidious movies.
Her IMDb runs on with Kroll Show and roughly seven to ten movies a year. — Bill Simmons
Lin Shaye describing what is happening and using the word insidious is the Leo from Once Upon a Time pointing-at-the-screen moment. — Bill Simmons
A participant proposes the Leonardo DiCaprio pointing-at-the-screen moment as a Rewatchables category, loving when the title is used organically in dialogue. — Chris Ryan
A reply says the best one ever is Face Off ("take his face off"). — Chris Ryan
