One host calls the thin romantic spark between Indy and Marion the movie’s biggest flaw; others defend Karen Allen and interpret Indy as constitutionally more committed to quests than relationships.
The long-lived working title Indiana Smith is ridiculed, and Karen Allen’s frustration with a much longer Marion backstory is weighed against Kasdan’s agreement that stripping it down improved the movie. — Bill Simmons
The ghosts and some optical effects look rough, while the red-line travel map is defended as efficient. — Bill Simmons
The panel questions Ronald Lacey’s Toht and Paul Freeman’s Belloq as underpowered villain casting, while also noting Toht’s visual menace and the story’s intent to make Nazis foolish.
The Nazi-aligned monkey is hated as an irritating comic animal whose espionage logic makes little sense. — Bill Simmons
Temple of Doom is criticized for violence, slapstick, tonal loss, and helping trigger PG-13, though Last Crusade later recovers the tone. — Bill Simmons
Kael’s refusal to admire the achievement and a cut scene presenting Indy as more of a playboy are debated as missed or defensible choices. — Bill Simmons
