Most Rewatchable Scene
Wendy discovers the manuscript and confronts Jack on the staircase
In the discussion (13)
Approx. transcript time · 00:36:20Read transcript
- The opening helicopter imagery and its theatrical impact are praised; old square television framing diminished it.
- Jack’s anger at Wendy’s writing interruption is nominated, with her hurt and the warning signs of their marriage discussed.
- Jack’s drink with Lloyd is praised for Nicholson’s expressive face and commitment.
- The manuscript discovery and stair confrontation are praised for both performances, staging, terror and the revelation of the repeated sentence.
- The manuscript’s typing is recounted, with the teardrop-shaped page and quoted indentation singled out.
- The panel debates how many pages Wendy needs to inspect before understanding the manuscript.
- The axe-through-the-bathroom-door sequence is nominated as an outstanding horror scene.
- The iconic bathroom attack is admired, but prior exposure to parodies diluted its terror for one viewer; Jack abandoning the attack prompts a question.
- The killing of Scatman Crothers is praised as shocking: Nicholson is hidden behind a pillar and the long return suggests a larger role.
- Danny’s maze escape is praised for his preparation and retracing of footprints.
- The second Gold Room visit and Grady conversation are added, along with the introductory hotel tour.
- The ice-cream conversation is praised for explicitly acknowledging the supernatural power.
- The manuscript discovery and staircase scene receive the final selection.
