Casting What-Ifs
Castle; Roberts; Basinger (uncertain); Quaid; original Jonah
This discussion recalls a choice from an earlier episode.
In the discussion (8)
Approx. transcript time · 01:10:00Read transcript
- Nick Castle reportedly lost Hook to Spielberg, then lost Sleepless to Ephron after creative conflict, eventually directing Dennis the Menace the same year.
- Internet casting lists are treated skeptically; Roberts turning down Annie is considered credible because she reportedly discussed it herself.
- Kim Basinger’s possible involvement is considered believable.
- Demi Moore is an intriguing hypothetical Annie but is considered too feisty or controlled; Robin Wright likewise lacks Ryan’s daffy quality.
- Bullock is considered too early in her career and Roberts too famous, potentially overpowering the film.
- Ryan’s accessible appeal and relatability are defended as essential to supporting a character who stalks a stranger.
- Ryan reportedly pushed for husband Dennis Quaid as Sam, but Ephron rejected the married pairing; the panel doubts Quaid could deliver the radio speech as effectively.
- The original Jonah was replaced after days; an assertion that Hanks pushed the firing is qualified by his documentary recollection that Ephron fired the child. Ross Malinger's later car-sales work is reported secondhand.