Who Won the Movie?
Taylor Sheridan
In the discussion (6)
Approx. transcript time · 01:53:28Read transcript
- Sheridan replaces an initial written Del Toro choice because the film launched his powerful career. — Bill Simmons
- A second answer explicitly agrees on Sheridan. — Bill Simmons
- Criticism of Sheridan’s later work is qualified as frustration at wasted writing talent, while his desire for control is understood. — Bill Simmons
- Another initial Del Toro choice acknowledges the Sheridan case; Sheridan is then reaffirmed, without a clearly countable additional voter. — Bill Simmons
- Villeneuve’s contribution is defended through the editing and refinement of the screenplay. — Craig Horlbeck
- The others distinguish artistic achievement from career impact, citing Villeneuve’s other breakthroughs and larger hits.
Podcast choices
- Speaker not identified
- Taylor Sheridan
- Speaker not identified
- Taylor Sheridan