Producer review
Both films loved; relationship differences praised; characters seem older than modern thirtysomethings
In the discussion (7)
Approx. transcript time · 01:39:21Read transcript
- The invited producer had watched both films for the first time on a plane, a setting the others consider appropriate.
- The first film is mesmerizing, especially its early-twenties dialogue and a compatible couple who do not agree on everything.
- The optimistic ending is loved, though Jesse’s initial smugness makes Celine’s attraction puzzling; their differences gradually soften them.
- Celine must be French; the Jennifer Connelly recast would not work for this viewer.
- Fear that a delayed sequel would spoil the original gives way to delight at the reversed perspectives and gradual renewed connection.
- Both films are called perfect, but these characters feel unusually weathered at 32 compared with contemporary thirty-year-olds who reach family milestones later.
- The extra eighty minutes are suspenseful and completely captivating; the reviewer declines to watch the third film yet.