Categories & segments

Sicario The Rewatchables
Sicario poster
Sicario

The Butch’s Girlfriend Award for the Weakest Link in the Film

Agency mechanics; Kate’s reporting insistence

In the discussion (2)
Approx. transcript time · 01:06:34Read transcript
  • The complex agency mechanics are a weak-link candidate; Garber’s explanatory scene is praised but considered late, and Kate’s official role is unpacked.
  • Kate’s insistence on reporting the operation after the tunnel is another weak-link/nitpick choice, despite a five-star overall opinion.
Sicario The Rewatchables
Sicario poster
Sicario

What’s Aged the Worst?

Kate’s smoking; sequel differences; supposed unattractiveness; Alejandro’s cartel connections; Reggie Wayne name; period-specific Juárez

In the discussion (5)
Approx. transcript time · 00:12:11Read transcript
  • Three adult films competing in 2015 is an early aged-worst comparison with current releases; a genre movie exceeding expectations makes Chris return to theaters immediately.
  • Kate’s smoking is criticized under aged-worst and a Tom Cruise bad-smoking award, with disagreement that she smokes convincingly.
  • The sequel is judged acceptable but different and unusually evil; an initial claim that it changed screenwriter is explicitly corrected to Sheridan.
  • Aged-worst objections include treating Blunt as unattractive, insufficient detail on Alejandro’s cartel connections and the script naming Reggie Wayne. The geopolitical premise is defended as plausible.
  • Juárez’s portrayal is discussed as tied to the writing period rather than the later city, with contemporary crime claims presented as the hosts’ reported research.
Sicario The Rewatchables
Sicario poster
Sicario

The Stephen A. Smith Hottest Take Award

Foreign-policy allegory; Yellowstone’s cost to cinema; Del Toro’s romantic reputation

In the discussion (4)
Approx. transcript time · 00:51:16Read transcript
  • A hottest take ranks the crossing alongside Heat’s robbery and The Dark Knight’s truck chase; the hosts recall the chaotic Grantland period.
  • A hottest take reads the film as an allegory of American foreign policy exploiting crises and desires for justice.
  • Another hottest take calls Yellowstone’s success a major loss for film screenwriting, with Mike White discussed as a different film-to-TV example.
  • Bill’s hottest take is that Del Toro’s reputation as a ladies’ man is underrecognized; purported relationships are recited as hearsay rather than independently established facts.
Sicario The Rewatchables
Sicario poster
Sicario

Recasting Couch

Early-2000s Kate Winslet

In the discussion (4)
Approx. transcript time · 00:29:52Read transcript
  • Blunt’s career run leads to approval of her casting, with early-2000s Kate Winslet imagined; credibility as an agent is separated from concerns about the character’s later moral reasoning.
  • Recasting discussion rejects Hathaway and Adams, considers the Blunt/Johansson Black Widow counterfactual, and credits Edge of Tomorrow for Blunt’s credible physicality.
  • Early-2000s Kate Winslet is the preferred hypothetical recast, qualified by Kate’s younger age.
  • Philadelphia replacing Juárez is a joking recasting-city suggestion tied to sports.
Displaying discussions 1045 - 1056 of 6801 in total