The story reportedly grew from Chip Beck laying up and Gary McCord repeatedly hitting a hazard; the hero cannot lay up.
The nickname's baseball origin feels random; a golf wager or childhood putting story would fit better. A crude alternative is a joke.
McCord reportedly received a requested $250,000 consulting/cameo fee; Costner reportedly performed most golf shots.
Daly and Eddie Pepperell incidents are cited as real Tin Cup comparisons.
Tiger Woods reportedly nearly ran out of his unique balls at the 2000 Open; Williams suggested iron without explaining, but Woods hit driver, correcting the initial assumption he obeyed.
The ball-replacement rule prompts jokes about refusing a rival and carrying many spares.
The insulted grandparents and child are reportedly Costner's parents and son.
Tin Cup Lake and the possible Rankin setting are discussed; Midland is corrected toward Odessa for Friday Night Lights.
A contemplated Cup at Q School sequel never happened, despite Shelton researching it, and is considered a missed opportunity.
Costner reportedly stopped playing afterward; a quoted oral-history anecdote has Mickelson collect a wager before his spectacular tree shot lands.

Janine Turner; Michelle Pfeiffer; Dennis Quaid; Alec Baldwin; disputed Costner and Leguizamo reports

In the discussion (10)

Approx. transcript time · 00:27:07Read transcript

Johnson reportedly lost the Untouchables role because of Miami Vice scheduling.
Baldwin was reportedly a casting possibility before a family pregnancy complication.
Janine Turner reportedly declined Molly.
Michelle Pfeiffer was reportedly approached before Russo.
Pfeiffer could have excelled but may seem too unattainable for a failing psychologist in rural Texas.
Dennis Quaid reportedly declined David Sims.
Baldwin reportedly accepted but withdrew three weeks before filming for family reasons.
Baldwin would establish villainy earlier and be less likable.
The reported offer of Shooter McGavin to Costner is rejected as implausible given his stardom.
The reported offer of Romeo to Leguizamo is doubted in light of his career position.

Golf physics, distances and decisions; implausible relationships; missing tournament resolution

In the discussion (11)

Approx. transcript time · 00:29:02Read transcript

The love triangle strains belief: Sims permits intimate lessons, Molly bypasses his expertise, and both her practice and their relationship have implausible West Texas geography.
The three-wood shot's gentle landing and backward spin are physically implausible for the stated distance and period equipment.
The seven-iron's earlier distance conflicts with the three-wood distance; wind and rollout only partly explain it.
Refusing the drop zone risks a life-changing win and prize money for an unnecessary demonstration.
Repeated misses should silence a horrified crowd; contemporary spectators and social media would instead ridicule him, unlike the stoic 1990s legend.
Nice par, David can mean the golf score or a romantic double entendre; Sims's actual finish is not shown.
The charity event's national broadcast and large purse seem disproportionate; broke friends freely breaking expensive clubs is implausible.
Drunkenness and sleep deprivation before the Open are self-sabotaging; consecutive 62 and 64 rounds should become an enormous story.
The producer's belated instruction to watch Roy makes no sense when he is already leading and in the final group.
The film never resolves Sims's possible playoff or shows Jacobsen celebrating, while the crowd occupies the green before play seems complete.
Golden Tassel head covers may refer to the strip club; Molly's instant friendship with Roy's former partner is another nitpick. A framed broken three-wood is desired.

In the discussion (1)

Approx. transcript time · 00:33:42Read transcript

Ebert gave three stars, praising dialogue and supporting characters while finding bloat.

Susan Sarandon as the strip-club owner

In the discussion (1)

Approx. transcript time · 01:25:58Read transcript

Which golf film is most beloved?

In the discussion (1)

Approx. transcript time · 01:45:19Read transcript

An explicit version of the measuring contest is joked about; Happy Gilmore likely wins a popularity poll, whereas Tin Cup is especially revered by golfers.