Dreyfuss trying-not-to-cry face perhaps best ever,lip bite/head drop repeated and conducting finale succeeds.
Young Terrence Howard likability,charisma,handsomeness raises career do-over and Will Smith-scale potential wish; off-set issues acknowledged.
Multi-decade aging,being pushed to care,rock-and-roll alarm,Howard funeral callback,Rowena coaching and credible conducting admired.
Cole sign for asshole enjoyed.
Title joked as ready porn title;Mr Hollands O Face proposed with speculation whether parody exists,not confirmed.

Second-career Dreyfuss, Jay Thomas, restrained crying and Stockman solo career; teacher-film and song-use alternatives differ.

In the discussion (8)

Approx. transcript time · 00:28:08Read transcript

Jay Thomas clear apex following Murphy Brown/Love and War television run.
Overall Dreyfuss no,but second career this over Stakeout/What About Bob agreed;100million success and star showcase.
Kelly uncertain against long-running TV show observed yesterday;Jay Thomas yes.
High-school teacher movies:Stand and Deliver favored over this;Dangerous Minds,187,Lean on Me candidates;Hoosiers/Coach Carter coaches excluded from narrow comparison.
Trying-not-to-cry face clear peak.
Someone to Watch Over Me song use finalist vs same-name Barringer/Rogers film, latter preferred due repeated/pivotal use;film praised despite rough last15minutes.
Others no,Portland floated without settled answer.
Sean Stockman solo career apex Visions of a Sunset;one of four best voices,possible solo breakout if huge hit,expected Wanié solo instead.

Ending and Beautiful Boy are distinct final preferences; other emotional teaching and family scenes admired despite flaws.

In the discussion (12)

Approx. transcript time · 00:34:36Read transcript

First strong scene about35minutes in:clarinet student breakthrough after desire to be good at something;music heart/fun beyond notes.
Coach chastises teacher for not teaching willing Lou Roy,followed by enjoyable but implausible rhythm montage.
Parade/kitchen discovery of Cole deafness,denial and Beethoven classroom reflection;Dreyfuss best acting to one speaker.
Headly I want to talk to my son kitchen scene excellent,perhaps unbeatable.
Principal retirement/favorite teacher and subsequent70s montage work;first not-crying face.
Rowena singing Someone to Watch Over Me after emotional coaching and wife realization well executed despite creepy plot;live voice essential.
Adult-looking24-year-old actress makes character age easier to forget;Rowena represents lost ambitions/former self,minor plot tweaks could avoid inappropriate romance.
Age-of-consent Google inquiry mentioned with surveillance joke;not legal verification.
Historical consent age16 is claimed as imagined defense,unverified and does not remove discomfort;Beautiful Boy works partly because Dreyfuss voice imperfect.
Named-for-song personal connection makes Beautiful Boy overwhelming;asserted post-Lennon-death release leads timing uncertainty.
Layoff talk with coach about expendability after30years relatable and effective.
Ending auditorium crowd/governor/opus succeeds;one ending preference vs Beautiful Boy preference.

Length, student-romance plot, marital behavior, dismissive treatment of deaf son and Dreyfuss’s later career.

In the discussion (6)

Approx. transcript time · 00:49:13Read transcript

143minutes too long;117–118minutes ideal.
Bus station plot:parents absent,midnight Portland–New York trip,leave before graduation and uncomfortable prolonged side-mouth kiss;teacher-support rewrite proposed.
Naming composition Rowena and lying Greek goddess then inviting wife to program implausibly careless potential adulterer behavior.
All-black cast remote-button fantasy,Danny Glover/Angela Bassett confrontation;era marital power imbalance considered but personal flaws emphasized.
Anti-sign-language stance and dismissing deaf son understanding Lennon death brutal.
Dreyfuss post-opus career decline despite age49 and nomination;W and Krippendorfs Tribe exceptions discussed.

Balthazar Getty as a retroactive that-guy; Jay Thomas rejected as too established.

In the discussion (1)

Approx. transcript time · 00:56:30Read transcript

Jay Thomas rejected as known star;Balthazar Getty proposed as reverted/retroactive that-guy,agreement.

Teenage Cole.

In the discussion (1)

Approx. transcript time · 00:56:56Read transcript

Rowena, with Howard considered and Dukakis a medalist.

In the discussion (3)

Approx. transcript time · 00:57:05Read transcript

Rowena/Jean Louisa Kelly vs Howard;Rowena15minutes must nail songs or movie unravels.
Macy one-note noted and defended as uptight60s foil;through his eyes,Holland misconduct is managerial nightmare and dismissal justice.
Rowena final agreement;Dukakis strong medalist but not winner.

A streaming teacher series across decades is endorsed.

In the discussion (1)

Approx. transcript time · 01:11:44Read transcript

Mustache, conductor stick, sheet music or drum-major uniform.

In the discussion (2)

Approx. transcript time · 01:22:09Read transcript

Dreyfuss mustache,used conductor stick and sheet music suggestions.
Drum-major uniform selected;teacher taking coveted student role another narcissism complaint.

Dreyfuss is the explicit choice; teachers receive a small-case alternative.

In the discussion (1)

Approx. transcript time · 01:24:15Read transcript

Dreyfuss explicit choice addressed Sean,career capstone and Oscar nomination;teachers tiny-case alternative,not settled second ballot.

Podcast choices