☆★☆★☆★☆★
Roger Ebert’s review is discussed: 2.5 stars
In the discussion (3)
- Ebert is reported to give Top Gun 2.5 out of four stars
- The panel discusses his praise for aerial scenes and criticism of dialogue
- The hosts find additional pleasure in the unintentional comedy
Magazine origins, Navy cooperation and production stories
In the discussion (14)
- The film is said to originate in California magazine’s Top Guns article
- The Navy’s involvement is reported to have changed location, language, a crash and Charlie’s role
- Paramount’s flight costs are discussed
- Pilot Art Scholl’s fatal production accident and the dedication are discussed; the machine transcript renders his name imperfectly
- Kilmer’s interruption is reported as improvised
- Edwards is reported as the only actor not to vomit during flights
- An early Maverick sequel concept about drones is discussed as then-current development history
- Kansas City Barbeque’s filming locations, fire and surviving piano are discussed
- Cruise’s lifts and a trench for McGillis are reported as height accommodations
- The alleged fine for quoting Top Gun is explicitly doubted
- Charlie’s inspiration Christine Fox and adviser Pete Pettigrew are discussed
- Randy Duke Cunningham’s claim to inspire Maverick is contrasted with filmmakers’ denial
- Tony Scott’s alleged payment to turn a ship for lighting is treated as an uncertain anecdote
- Earlier discussion attributes the added elevator and love scenes to test-screening feedback and explains costume/lighting continuity fixes
A quiz matching Top Gun call signs to character names
In the discussion (4)
- The quiz gives Goose as Nick Bradshaw and Iceman as Tom Kazansky
- Charlie is Charlotte Blackwood; Jester is Rick Heatherly
- Viper is Mike Metcalf and Slider is Ron Kerner
- Cougar and Merlin are given as Bill Cortell and Sam Wells; transcript spelling remains a secondary source
Matthew Modine, Linda Fiorentino and other reported alternatives
In the discussion (8)
- Modine is said to have declined Maverick because of the military politics
- Travolta’s asking price is reported as a barrier, with uncertainty around the wider internet list
- Fiorentino is reported to have declined Charlie because of the glorification of war
- Ally Sheedy is reported to have doubted demand for a fighter-pilot movie
- Julianne Phillips is mentioned for Charlie and Jon Voight for Viper
- Modine is considered a plausible alternative Maverick
- Robert Downey Jr. as Maverick, or as Iceman opposite Kilmer, is imagined
- Judd Nelson and Charlie Sheen are discussed as very different possibilities
Goose’s ejection, the dog tags and Maverick’s instant teaching career
In the discussion (8)
- Maverick leaves volleyball before its resolution
- The ejection mechanism is questioned as a design flaw
- Hollywood’s rapid rescue and cheerful return after his plane is hit seem implausible
- Throwing Goose’s dog tags away deprives his widow and son of them
- The crowded bar falls silent implausibly for the song
- Charlie’s older bar companion is debated as a date versus colleague
- Maverick opts to teach immediately after graduating and one battle
- An aside calls this an apex for USA Today’s sports section
The film’s erotic intent, Goose’s death and Charlie’s interest in Maverick
In the discussion (12)
- Was the homoeroticism intentional? The panel discusses Scott’s quote and the film’s broader salesmanship
- Why make Hot Shots when Top Gun already resembles parody? The panel notes viewers originally took it seriously
- Why was Kilmer not nominated for a supporting Oscar?
- Maverick ending up with Goose’s widow is floated
- Why are the ship interiors so hot and smoky?
- Is Goose among the most upsetting unexpected screen deaths? Hooch, Fredo, Mickey, the Champ, Apollo and Elias are compared
- The predictability of Goose’s death is disputed
- Why play volleyball in jeans?
- What does Charlie do after Maverick leaves dinner?
- Charlie’s desire and the actors’ on-screen chemistry prompt an extended disagreement
- Does Charlie return for Maverick or for more information about MiGs?
- These are speculative readings of fictional characters, not facts about the actors