Picking Nits
The coffin escape, whether Diane ditched Jeff, the missing family search, Rita’s job and sudden sobriety, failure to call police, Barney’s exposure, family behavior, drug timing, grave logistics, and Jeff’s honesty with police
In the discussion (13)
Approx. transcript time · 00:35:29Read transcript
- If death in the coffin is otherwise certain, the panel debates using the lighter to burn or loosen the lid, while acknowledging smoke inhalation. — Bill Simmons
- Jeff never appears to treat Diane simply ditching him after their fight as a live possibility. — Chris Ryan
- Diane’s parents, siblings, and friends are strangely absent from the three-year search. — Chris Ryan
- Jeff remains on local television yet is treated as a laughing stock despite Diane leaving no financial trace. — Chris Ryan
- The panel asks if Rita is still a waitress or works at the bar and says it has no idea how she makes money. — Bill Simmons
- Jeff should call police immediately after Barney identifies himself and survives the beating. — Bill Simmons
- Barney uses his real name and school, giving Jeff obvious ways to expose him even without a murder charge. — Chris Ryan
- Rita goes from drinking heavily at the bar to sober police-station problem solving within about five minutes. — Bill Simmons
- Barney’s daughter and wife do not react plausibly to his secretive cabin behavior. — Bill Simmons
- The panel asks why the daughter wants her father to cheat on her mother so badly. — Bill Simmons
- The chloroform would need to keep Jeff unconscious through a drive, transport, and burial that seem longer than shown. — Bill Simmons
- An open grave near the cabin would be difficult to hide from visitors. — Bill Simmons
- When police ask whether the vanished couple fought, the proposed answer is no so they can start looking. — Chris Ryan