What’s Aged the Worst?
The second hour, the Dave Chappelle detour, the abrupt marriage, the weak SNL pop song, and the movie’s confused pop-music argument age worst.
In the discussion (6)
Approx. transcript time · 00:47:14Read transcript
- The second hour is harder to rewatch than the first and begins to grind around the Dave Chappelle section.
- Chappelle performs well, but the material does not explain why his character and the sudden marriage are necessary.
- The SNL scene supplies cool backstage access, but the song itself is judged poor.
- Jackson’s suicide is defended as necessary tragedy and the culmination of earlier addiction and depression signals.
- “Why Did You Do That?” is criticized as neither a plausible hit nor a clear intentional parody.
- The movie appears to condemn pop music without showing why Gaga’s character loses agency or why Jackson Maine’s style is more authentic.